Table 2– Univariate analysis of individuals’ variables at baseline comparing mean values and/or proportion of patients according to whether or not (yes or no, respectively) an improvement larger than the mimimum clinically important difference (MCID) was seen in each pulmonary rehabilitation outcome
Variable (MCID)
6MWD (+54 m)MRC score (-1 point)SGRQ score (-4 points)
YesNop-valueYesNop-valueYesNop-value
Age yrs67.2±7.668.2±7.40.07268.2±7.868.0±7.20.80868.1±7.668.8±6.90.524
Males/females n107/35123/420.871158/6069/:200.162149/5765/360.753
BMI kg·m−227.5±4.726.8±5.60.28327.6±5.626.6±4.00.15826.7±3.726.2±4.30.400
FEV1 % pred49.3±13.049.8±14.90.75549.0±14.551.0±13.00.29449.4±14.148.7±17.10.730
Charlson score2.58±1.32.73±1.10.3402.66±1.22.65±1.10.9792.56±1.02.75±1.40.375
Pa,O2 mmHg71.4±9.672.3±9.90.45972.0±10.171.0±8.90.45671.3±9.874.9±10.10.012
Pa,CO2 mmHg41.8±5.641.0±5.20.21342.0±5.740.3±4.40.02542.0±5.340.6±5.30.061
Baseline 6MWD372.3±85.9418.0±73.40.001389.5±77.9421.8±75.80.001406.4±73.6396.7±81.20.356
Baseline MRC3.22±0.83.20±0.80.8273.55±0.62.36±0.60.0013.21±0.83.33±0.90.311
Baseline SGRQ42.8±16.442.6±15.40.93542.8±15.641.0±16.20.40844.5±15.538.3±15.90.005
Comorbidities
 Single
  Chronic Heart Failure12 (40)18 (60)0.47011 (34)19 (62)0.33621 (70)9 (30)0.177
  Diabetes21 (51)20 (49)0.49314 (34)27 (66)0.49026 (63)15 (37)0.711
  Hypertension57 (48)62 (52)0.64632 (27)87 (73)0.26575 (63)44 (37)0.497
  Coronary disease14 (38)23 (62)0.27426 (70)11 (30)0.54219 (51)18 (49)0.709
  Dyslipidaemia23 (51)22 (49)0.47927 (60)18 (40)0.57028 (62)17 (38)0.537
  Osteoporosis7 (24)22 (76)0.01216 (55)13 (45)0.96418 (62)11 (38)0.256
  Other diseases15 (41)22 (59)0.73324 (65)13 (35)0.45027 (73)10 (27)0.046
 Aggregated
  Heart disease24 (40)36 (60)0.27937 (62)23 (38)0.42539 (65)21 (35)0.677
  Metabolic disease73 (46)85 (54)0.985118 (75)40 (25)0.069103 (65)55 (35)0.606
  Skeletal disease7 (24)22 (76)0.01216 (55)13 (45)0.96418 (62)11 (38)0.256
 Comorbid categories
  057 (49)60 (51)0.49771 (61)46 (39)0.01688 (75)29 (25)0.365
  148 (45)58 (55)0.80489 (84)17 (16)0.00070 (66)47 (44)0.073
  ≥237 (44)47 (56)0.63459 (70)25 (30)0.20560 (71)24 (29)0.239
  • Data are presented as mean±sd or n (%), unless otherwise stated. 6MWD: 6-min walk distance; MRC: Medical Research Council dyspnoea scale; SGRQ: St George’s Respiratory Questionnaire; BMI: body mass index; FEV1: forced expiratory volume in 1 s; % pred: % predicted; Pa,O2: arterial oxygen tension; Pa,CO2: arterial carbon dioxide tension. Bold indicates statistically significant p-values.