Table 5

Reported excessive bronchoconstriction# (EB) caused by sputum induction in asthmatic subjects

First author [Ref.]Subjects nAsthma charsEB# n (%)Induction procedureMaximal fall in FEV1
BaselineSafety assessmentFEV1 % predsal %Time minFall %
FEV1 % predTypeInterval minInterruptionPre­BDPost­BD
Pin 117Mild, stable1 (5.8)88.9FEV15.0fall ≥20%+NANANANA30
Pizzichini 610exac4 (13.0)74.3FEV11–2fall ≥20%+,§NA93.03.03.042
Wong 378Mild­to­moderate11 (14.0)>60.0FEV120fall ≥20%+51.063.03.02069
Hunter 536Mild, stable3 (8.3)82.6FEV15.0fall ≥20%+NANANANA23
Vlachos­Mayer 14304Mild­to­severe24 (8.0)73.1FEV17 or 1–2fall ≥20%+,§75.0NA5.02150
Pizzichini 3431Mild­to­severeƒ10 (32)73.9FEV17 or 1–2fall ≥20%+,§67.577.53.07.053
  • chars: characteristics

  • EB: excessive bronchoconstriction

  • FEV1: forced expiratory volume in one second

  • % pred: percentage of the predicted value

  • BD: bronchodilator

  • PT: pretreatment

  • sal: saline

  • NA: not available

  • exac: exacerbation

  • #: as defined by a fall in FEV1 of ≥20%

  • : all subjects pretreated with bronchodilator (200 µg salbutamol)

  • +: or specimen obtained

  • §: or patient expiratory discomfort

  • ƒ: steroid­naive