Table 7—

Meta-analysis of studies including nonsmall cell lung cancer (NSCLC) of any stage, with their characteristics

First author [ref. no.]MethodQS %Patients np53+ %HR95% CI
Fujino 32IHC-;DO-;77091581.711.05–2.78
Greatens 36PCR-;SSCP55101401.811.00–3.26
Hayakawa 41IHC-;DO-;75836691.550.51–4.71
Kim 10IHC79238181.000.55–1.82
Levesque 59ELISA6371482.471.03–5.92
Mitsudomi 55PCR-;SSCP53120431.921.17–3.15
Murakami 70PCR-;DGGE6354391.120.60–2.08
Ohsaki 74IHC-;DO-;75499441.470.91–2.37
Quantin 78IHC-;18017189520.850.46–1.60
Tagawa 83PCR-;SSCP2467341.440.59–3.52
Xu [92]IHC5766561.300.79–2.13
Overall 581032441.441.20–1.72
  • QS: quality score

  • p53+: presence of an abnormality of p53

  • HR: hazard ratio

  • CI: confidence interval

  • IHC-;DO-;7: immunohistochemistry with monoclonal antibody DO-;7

  • PCR: polymerase chain reaction

  • SSCP: single-strand conformation polymorphism method

  • DGGE: denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis

  • IHC-;1801: immunohistochemistry with monoclonal antibody 1801

  • IHC: immunohistochemistry with antibodies other than DO-;7 or 1801

  • ELISA: enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay technique

  • Group of NSCLC all stages, n=11

  • Chi-;squared statistic for heterogeneity = 8.70, 10 degrees of freedom, p=0.56