Table 2—

Results of the methodological assessment by the European Lung Cancer Working Party score

Studies nGlobal score %Design*Laboratory methodology*Genera-lizability*Results analysis*
All studies7454.84.05.76.75.6
Evaluated for the MA5654.84.05.76.65.6
Noevaluated for the MA1854.64.55.76.65.0
p-;value0.720.830.890.810.16
Positive3055.14.46.46.66.2
Negative4454.34.05.76.63.7
p-;value0.240.570.490.940.02
IHC3556.54.06.46.66.2
MB1452.44.04.06.65.6
p-;value0.070.310.00020.290.88
  • Score distributions are summarized by the median values

  • *: score out of 10

  • Positive: studies identifying p53 positivity as significant poor prognostic factor for survival

  • Negative: studies reporting nonsignificant results, or identifying p53 positivity as associated with better survival

  • IHC: immunohistochemistry

  • MB: molecular biology

  • MA: meta-analysis