TABLE 3

Limitations and advantages of exercise testing and fluid loading in the assessment of pulmonary hypertension

Exercise testingFluid loading
Clinical relevance for symptom assessment+ + ++
Clinical relevance for differential diagnosis++ + +
Main advantagesRespects the pathophysiology; comprehensive test, allowing for additional insights in pulmonary vascular disease (dynamic pulmonary vascular resistance); complementary with cardiopulmonary exercise testingEasy to perform, no specific setting; minimal risk of misinterpretation of pressures reading; better established cut-off defining abnormal increase in pulmonary arterial wedge pressure
Main limitationsRequires a specific complex setting; expertise in conducting the test; pressure reading during exercise; range of normal response uncertainUnknown response in disease state; age dependency of response
Standardised protocol+/−+ +