TABLE 3

Performance of different algorithms for Xpert tests saved and cases missed in Bangladesh

CAD scorePeople tested on Xpert nXpert tests saved %MTB+ cases missed n (%)
Direct Xpert testing
 All referral groupsNA17 066NANA
 Private providersNA12 340NANA
 NTP facilitiesNA2316NANA
 Walk-insNA2410NANA
 Senior (≥55 years)NA4485NANA
 Middle age (25–55 years)NA8991NANA
 Young adult (≤25 years)NA3590NANA
Radiologist→Xpert
 AllNA842851249 (9)
 Private providersNA666246200 (10)
 NTP facilitiesNA11145228 (7)
 Walk-insNA6527321 (11)
 Senior (≥55 years)NA27543958 (10)
 Middle age (25–55 years)NA409055128 (10)
 Young adult (≤25 years)NA15845663 (8)
CAD4TB→Xpert
 Set CAD to match radiologist sensitivity
  All6310 91236249 (9)
  Private providers64838832195 (10)
  NTP facilities6014523737 (9)
  Walk-ins5611955018 (10)
  Senior (≥55 years)8231293053 (9)
  Middle age (25–55 years)61539140123 (10)
  Young adult (≤25 years)5621104179 (10)
 Set CAD to reduce Xpert tests by ∼50%
  All80848850473 (18)
  Private providers84622650423 (21)
  NTP facilities7511625068 (17)
  Walk-ins5611955018 (10)
  Senior (≥55 years)94222051144 (26)
  Middle age (25–55 years)74450050194 (15)
  Young adult (≤25 years)66178550105 (13)
  • MTB+: Mycobacterium tuberculosis-positive; CAD4TB: computer automated detection of TB software; NTP: National TB Program.