TABLE 1

Baseline characteristics of studies included in the meta-analysis

Study [ref.]Study designRegion of studyStudy size nAge at follow up time yearsBMI percentileAsthma control in 12 months/6 monthsAsthma exacerbations in 12 months/6 monthsOverweight/ Obesity %Well-controlled asthma %Hospitalisation %ED visits %OCS use %
BREATHECross-sectionalUK, Scotland13184–18ObesityOCS use; hospitalisation due to asthma13.415.225.9
PACMANCross-sectionalNetherlands6484–12ObesityACQOCS use; ED visits10.359.06.25.1
PAGESCross-sectionalUK, Scotland4224–17ObesityACTOCS use; hospitalisation due to asthma15.436.214.339.4
Sasaki [11]Cross-sectionalJapan30666–11ObesityACT11.885.4
Lang [12]Cross-sectionalUSA5610–17Overweight; obesityACQ62.5 (overweight); 41.1 (obesity)37.5
Lang [15]Multicentre clinical trial#USA306ObesityACQ3133.7
Lang [16]Multicentre clinical trial#USA1076–17ObesityACQ23.471
Kattan [17]Randomised clinical trial#USA36812–20ObesityACT35.189.1
Borrell [14]Cross-sectionalUSA21748–19Overweight; obesityAsthma control35.617.6
Sah [24]Cross-sectionalUSA269ObesityHospitalisation due to asthma; ED visits+24.932.715.6
Schatz [19]CohortUSA10 7005–17ObesityOCS use§28.111.7
Quinto [20]CohortUSA32 3215–17Overweight; obesityHospitalisation and ED visits due to asthma; OCS use19.3 (overweight); 30.0 (obesity)NANANA
Luder [23]Cross-sectionalUSA2092–18OverweightHospitalisation due to asthmaƒ; ED visits##39.723.972.2
Hom [21]CohortUSA1836–18OverweightHospitalisation due to asthma; ED visits¶¶59.036.130.1
  • #: findings in these three studies are the results of post hoc analyses of data from randomised clinical trials not specifically designed to assess the effect of obesity on asthma outcomes; : asthma control based on NHLBI guidelines (meeting at least three criteria has been defined as poor asthma control); +: one time emergency department (ED) visit over the preceding 12 months; §: within last 7 days of asthma exacerbations diagnosis; ƒ: ≥3 times hospitalisation per year; ##: ≥10 ED visits during the past year; ¶¶: ≥1 ED visits during the past 30 days. BMI: body mass index; OCS: oral corticosteroid; ACQ: Asthma Control Questionnaire; ACT: Asthma Control Test; NA: not available.