TABLE 1

General characteristics of the trials

First author [ref.]YearJournalCompany#Disease stageStandard armExperimental arm(s)
First-line setting
 Negoro [13]2003Br J Cancer3IIIB–IVCisplatin+vindesineIrinotecan
 Rosell [14]2002Ann Oncol2III–IVCisplatin+paclitaxelCarboplatin+paclitaxel
 Fossella [15]2003J Clin Oncol3IIIB–IVCisplatin+vinorelbineCisplatin+docetaxel
Carboplatin+docetaxel
 Ohe [16]2007Ann Oncol3IIIB–IVCisplatin+irinotecanCarboplatin+paclitaxel
Cisplatin+gemcitabine
Cisplatin+vinorelbine
 Novello [17]2007Ann Oncol1IVCisplatin+gemcitabine (2 cycles) followed by 3 further cycles in nonprogressive patientsCisplatin-gemcitabine (2 cycles) followed by 3 cycles of gemcitabine in nonprogressive patients
 Park [18]2007J Clin Oncol1IIIB–IV4 cycles of cisplatin-based CT in patients nonprogressive after 2 cycles2 cycles of cisplatin based CT in patients nonprogressive after 2 cycles
 Scagliotti [19]2008J Clin Oncol2IIIB–IVCisplatin+gemcitabineCisplatin+pemetrexed
 Heymach [20]2008J Clin Oncol2IIIB–IVCarboplatin+paclitaxelVandetanib
Vandetanib+paclitaxel+carboplatin (superiority assumption for this arm)
 Mok [21]2009N Engl J Med2IIIB–IVCarboplatin+paclitaxelGefitinib
 Okamoto [22]2010J Clin Oncol3IIIB–IVCarboplatin+paclitaxelCarboplatin+S-1
 Lee [23]2013Clin Lung Cancer3IIIB–IVCisplatin+paclitaxelPaclitaxel-loaded polymeric micelle+cisplatin
Second-line settingIIIB–IV
 Schuette [24]2005J Clin Oncol3IIIB–IVDocetaxel (3-weekly regimen)Docetaxel (weekly regimen)
 Hanna [25]2004J Clin Oncol2IIIB–IVDocetaxelPemetrexed
 Ramlau [26]2006J Clin Oncol2IIIB–IVDocetaxelTopotecan
 Krzakowski [27]2010J Clin Oncol2IIIB–IVDocetaxelVinflunine
 Maruyama [28]2008J Clin Oncol2IIIB–IVDocetaxelGefitinib
 Kim [29]2008Lancet2IIIB–IVDocetaxelGefinitib
 Li [30]2012Pulm Pharm Ther3IIIB–IVDocetaxelPemetrexed
 Natale [31]2011J Clin Oncol2IIIB–IVErlotinibVandetanib
 Shi [32]2013Lancet Oncol2IIIB–IVGefitinibIcotinib
  • The studies are ordered by the date of inclusion of the first patient in the study. CT: chemotherapy. #: involvement of a pharmaceutical company was scored as 1 (no), 2 (yes, grant provided and company members as authors) or 3 (uncertain, grant provided but real role of company members not reported); : an oral fluoropyrimidine agent.