Table 2– Selected sensory and physiological parameters at rest, the HEWR, and peak exercise
RestHEWR (60 W)Peak
ControlsMild COPDControlsMild COPDControlsMild COPD
Dyspnoea Borg scale0.0±0.00.1±0.20.6±0.71.4±1.4*6.0±3.14.7±1.8
Leg discomfort Borg scale0.1±0.30.1±0.20.7±0.72.1±1.7**6.8±3.25.4±1.8
VO2 L·min−10.35±0.120.32±0.081.13±0.121.11±0.172.55±0.881.61±0.48***
Work rate W178±62102±30***
Heart rate beats·min−173±1581±13101±18116±17*155±16142±17*
SaO2 %97±197±297±196±294±395±2
VE L·min−110.4±3.611.2±3.127.7±4.333.9±8.1*92.7±30.155.7±16.4***
VT L0.79±0.240.69±0.181.33±0.191.32±0.282.35±0.691.57±0.44***
fR breaths·min−114.3±5.217.2±5.121.4±4.526.9±8.9*39.5±6.836.1±7.2
VE/VCO240.0±4.946.3±7.6**28.9±2.233.3±4.0***33.0±4.333.3±4.1
PETCO2 mmHg35.1±2.732.3±3.6*39.9±3.235.2±4.5**33.6±4.033.6±3.9
IC L3.06±0.872.56±0.613.31±0.842.53±0.52**3.16±0.802.29±0.46***
ΔIC L0.25±0.34−0.03±0.38*0.10±0.53−0.28±0.47*
IRV L2.27±0.781.87±0.551.98±0.861.21±0.40**0.81±0.340.71±0.40
EELV/TLC %48.2±8.655.9±9.3*43.6±8.756.8±5.8***46.5±7.261.1±3.4***
EILV/TLC %61.7±8.767.8±8.467.0±10.279.6±5.2***86.3±5.387.9±6.4
Work of breathing J·min−13±14±3*16±732±17**177±11287±38**
EMGdi/EMGdi,max%7.8±4.312.8±3.4**17.9±11.737.3±17.3***59.3±12.659.5±17.5
(EMGdi/EMGdi,max)/(Pdi/Pdi,max)0.30±0.200.35±0.100.52±0.270.87±0.38**1.31±0.401.26±0.41
Pes/Pes,max %8.4±4.010.5±3.314.6±5.023.3±7.7***38.5±11.938.2±8.1
VMR (ΔPgPes)−1.26±1.01−1.62±1.28−0.34±0.64−0.14±0.580.00±0.480.13±0.88
  • Data are presented as mean±sd. HEWR: highest equivalent work rate; COPD: chronic obstructive pulmonary disease; VO2: oxygen uptake; SaO2: arterial oxygen saturation; VE: minute ventilation; VT: tidal volume; fR: respiratory frequency; VCO2: carbon dioxide production; PETCO2: end-tidal carbon dioxide tension; IC: inspiratory capacity; ΔIC: change in IC from rest; IRV: inspiratory reserve volume; EELV: end-expiratory lung volume; TLC: total lung capacity; EILV: end-inspiratory lung volume; EMGdi: diaphragmatic electromyography; EMGdi,max: maximal EMGdi; Pdi: transdiaphragmatic pressure; Pdi,max: maximal Pdi; Pes: tidal oesophageal pressure; Pes,max: maximal Pes; VMR: ventilatory muscle recruitment; ΔPg: change in gastric pressure. *: p<0.05; **: p<0.01; ***: p<0.001.