To the Editors:
Migliori et al. 1 have written a commendable editorial about the challenges to science presented by the emergence of extensively drug-resistant tuberculosis (XDR-TB) as a named entity. We wish to clarify the origin and development of the term “XDR-TB”.
As noted by Migliori et al. 1, resistance to second-line drugs is not a new phenomenon. Despite years of anecdotal reports about “super bugs” and TB strains (predominantly in the former Soviet Union and Asia) with resistance to six, seven and eight or more anti-TB drugs, the global distribution of TB strains with concurrent resistance to multiple second-line drugs had not been previously reported.
The concept and term XDR-TB as a distinct nosological entity were first developed by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) in March 2005 and were introduced into public use in October 2005 at the 36th World Conference on Lung Health in Paris, France 2, 3. At that meeting, data on second-line drug resistance from a joint global survey of Supranational TB Reference Laboratories conducted by the CDC and the World Health Organization (WHO), as well as treatment outcomes of XDR-TB patients in Latvia, were first presented using the working definition later published in 2006. Shortly thereafter, a cluster of TB deaths with resistance to multiple second-line drugs (called “highly drug-resistant TB” by the scientists) in HIV-infected persons in rural KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa, was presented at the 13th Conference on Retroviruses and Opportunistic Infections (Denver, CO, USA) in February 2006 4. At the time and for reasons that are unclear, this report did not reach the attention of the global public health community, perhaps because this new “entity” in TB control had not yet been given a new name. Shortly thereafter, the original definition for XDR-TB was first published in March 2006 5; it was later revised in October 2006 at an emergency meeting of the Global Task Force on XDR-TB and posted on the WHO website. The revised definition was simultaneously published in November 2006 in the Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report 6 and in the WHO’s Weekly Epidemiologic Record 7.
- © ERS Journals Ltd