ࡱ > 5 7 4 9 bjbj W m m m D ( 6 8 8 8 8 8 8 $ Y ! \ m " \ q 8 m l 6 U 0\a X 0 " j " " m x \ \ & " : Appendix 4
ERS LAM task force consensus scores
To reach the best consensus on each point members of the Core, Consultant and Review panels graded all responses according to their level of agreement on a 9 point Likert scale as shown below.
9 Extremely appropriate: option of choice
7-8 Appropriate: a first-line option you would often use.
4-6 Equivocal: a second-line option you would sometimes use (eg, after first line treatment had failed).
2-3 Usually inappropriate: at most, a third-line option you would rarely use.
1 Extremely inappropriate: an option you would never use
Figure shows a box (interquartile range) and whisker (range) plot of the final Likert scores for all respondents for all Task force recommendations.
Task force recommendation
From these responses the final consensus was determined according to the criteria in the table below ADDIN EN.CITE Baumann200162826282628217Baumann, Michael H.Strange, CharlieHeffner, John E.Light, RichardKirby, Thomas J.Klein, JeffreyLuketich, James D.Panacek, Edward A.Sahn, Steven A.Management of Spontaneous Pneumothorax : An American College of Chest Physicians Delphi Consensus StatementChest %R 10.1378/chest.119.2.590Chest %R 10.1378/chest.119.2.590590-60211922001February 1, 2001http://www.chestjournal.org/cgi/content/abstract/119/2/590 [1].
TermDefinitionPerfect consensusAll respondents agree on an answerVery good consensusMedian and middle 50% (interquartile range) of respondents are found at one integer (eg, median and interquartile range are both at 8) or 80% of respondents are within one integer of the median (eg, median is 8, 80% respondents are from 7 to 9)Good consensus50% of respondents are within one integer of the median (eg, median is 8, 50% of respondents are from 7 to 9) or 80% of the respondents are within two integers of the median (eg, median is 7, 80% of respondents are from 5 to 9).Some consensus50% or respondents are within two integers of the median (eg, median is 7, 50% of respondents are from 5 to 9) or 80% of respondents are within three integers of the median (eg, median is 6, 80% of respondents are from 3 to 9).No consensusAll other responses.References
ADDIN EN.REFLIST 1. Baumann MH, Strange C, Heffner JE, Light R, Kirby TJ, Klein J, Luketich JD, Panacek EA, Sahn SA. Management of Spontaneous Pneumothorax : An American College of Chest Physicians Delphi Consensus Statement. Chest 2001: 119(2): 590-602.
EMBED Prism5.Document
0 2 g k l q | # > E Z ] w ~
-
5
K
L
M
N
ճլܒz h5 h; j h5 h; UmH nH u h5 h; 5h5 hf 6] h5 hf \h5 h#> h5 hf h5 h h5 h 6] h5 hMe 6] h5 hMe h5 h 5h5 hL~z 5h5 h( 5>* h5 hL~z 5>*- 0 1 2 Z
K
L
M
$a$gd; $0^`0a$gd $a$gd $a$gdL~z
m n # . @ A c d x y < > m n } ~ - / b c r s ! # V W d e y z { l ܢ h5 hcl h5 hcl 5h5 h~m 5h5 h+ 6] h5 h+ 5h5 h+ 5\ h5 hr j h5 hcl Uh5 h5 h)0= h5 h; h5 h+ = # . $$^&`#$/ If a$gd+ $a$gd; . / A d m m $$^&`#$/ If a$gd+ kd $$If F 0 #
6`^ 0 "$6 4 4
F a d e y n m m $$^&`#$/ If a$gd+ kd $$If F 0 #
6`^ 0 "$6 4 4
F a n o ~ c m m $$^&`#$/ If a$gd+ kdH $$If F 0 #
6`^ 0 "$6 4 4
F a c d s W m m $$^&`#$/ If a$gd+ kd $$If F 0 #
6`^ 0 "$6 4 4
F a W X e z m m $$^&`#$/ If a$gd+ kd $$If F 0 #
6`^ 0 "$6 4 4
F a z { ~ ~ q q q l ~ ~ q gdL~z V^`Vgd( kd4 $$If F 0 #
6`^ 0 "$6 4 4
F a
l r ǿһ h% j hP$e UjM
hP$e UVhP$e j hP$e Uh5 h; j h5 hcl Uh5 hr h5 h`>U 6 2 1h:pL~z . A!"#$% @=Z+ Þ>~^Eó 3 @w 4 (+ x}UՕ)*)J(oEQѨDE DTZ7j+ڦ1ƤM:Aq6VcC1&7kݚRRތ]gϳ5s/dY6S,{e,,[9&˚8,ɞ9˶eu%Ќ`^eonm K^Mv#ۀ\owV8F.!x
byZYȞ&c~Ge+Z<%Gyj6nJ> v7n67-s]@> ߶36lYofb?x_ME@c{*h*o5lavN6);Dž [JnsWw]܆چw,__kƛlh%!oA1;/}A1{9o1uc߮^.:eS^1;bMhͦv@
aX}\37겙tpn/q
Ko?⁌iyq=놥lc$Zx(yp}?1VD0lQ8_>3ˆ1I{S6!۫ƹs,Qq)"7 jzxfN)ǻƃȣ 8D٢z8ctZT^Oͫ.Z:pSΩ]pnEe墹.hlI{95cojxn[l>1{sOI^0q_ƅ.ΙA%qycN\4zqeͱ5d5؉nc=1[8vw;W؉~>|~q
N\4u6mp}s-l|;؉Sck#9wZ+gv>ވ{9>uzEȴ!d{?éE\&Y=+\\7.?0.ww˴\qdYU#e;y,)ƿrY5]f_u!.qSˋ=Қ/Aq>9RzY/i]&
eqйe.k7.EklvsKpuS>x_;S#q} ~W֬m7p>-vG\o{9o]/.ͯ7ܺo݅3~#pA80Ϗ#k*߸q.N]&\flda>sB<3'"NkIcK9Zop#p"Nqz198]c|28RSlepA'-/r\Vӵi,|]@p+E|ߧ|5}wuH1z~/:|n"}ց<6҅@|gi6{C5~<%&.⍷q/8Gލǵ[1}+ޗ) -=j!_zd"(^:;Wʠ)
/:lV;jJ-;QG?a~~0~"[~~_7+cV7
~zJ?"~w~}oq_~QrK7P;fa\K["~TAʯyQ-1oF'ƴh~ޏq)?"~S ~PZבso{R~)~Oˌp|#p^CcP)Ee{4{k:R{O&r'.q^/ܧ)kaiA=>{
ẋsX>
Sl8.lqNms