A randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled study was conducted to evaluate the effects of theophylline and acetazolamide in the treatment of sleep-disordered breathing (SDB) after fast ascent to high altitude (3,454 m).
The study was conducted at a high-altitude research laboratory and included 30 healthy male volunteers. Study medication was either oral slow release theophylline (2×250 mg·day−1), oral acetazolamide (2×250 mg·day−1) or a matched placebo tablet. Polysomnographic measurements were performed during two consecutive nights, and acute mountain sickness, pulse rate, oxyhaemoglobin saturation and arterial blood gases were assessed three times a day.
Without active medication, the apnoea/hypopnoea index (AHI) was highly pathological (median 16.2·h−1, range 2–92). Both theophylline and acetazolamide normalised SDB (median AHI 2.5·h−1, range 0–11; 4.2·h−1, range 0–19, respectively) and reduced oxyhaemoglobin desaturations during sleep (median desaturation index placebo 41.5·h−1, range 6–114; acetazolamide 6.5·h−1, range 3–28; theophylline 8.5·h−1, range 3–32). Compared with the high amount of central apnoeas or hypopnoeas, the number of obstructive events during sleep was very low in all groups (<4·h−1). In contrast to theophylline, acetazolamide significantly improved basal oxyhaemoglobin saturation during sleep (86.2±1.7% versus 81.0±3.0%).
The authors conclude that both oral slow release theophylline and acetazolamide are effective to normalise high-altitude sleep-disordered breathing.
This study was supported by Deutsche Akademie für Flug- und Reisemedizin, Frankfurt and Radiometer Inc., Munich, Germany.
Sleep-disordered breathing (SDB) of the Cheyne-Stokes type is commonly found during sleep at high altitude 1–3. This typical breathing pattern with waxing and waning of the tidal volume is associated with profound desaturations and reduced overall oxygen saturation during sleep, but its association with an increased number of arousals is a matter of ongoing debate 4, 5. The use of acetazolamide at high altitude is known to reduce the time spent with periodic breathing, to improve overall oxygen saturation during sleep and to reduce the number of arousals 6.
Acetazolamide inhibits the renal enzyme carbonic anhydrase, which leads to metabolic acidosis, and, as a result, increases ventilation and oxygenation. The beneficial effects of this drug at high altitude are thought to be due to this improved oxygenation. Although serious side-effects of acetazolamide are uncommon, an alternative treatment option would be desirable for patients with known sulphonamide intolerance. In a previous, prospective, randomised study, the authors were able to show that theophylline has a positive impact on symptoms of acute mountain sickness (AMS), compared with placebo 7. As theophylline was shown to be effective in reducing periodic breathing in premature newborns and in patients with severe heart failure 8, 9, a similar effect in high-altitude periodic breathing could be assumed.
Therefore, a randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled study was conducted to evaluate the effect of theophylline andacetazolamide on periodic breathing and arterial oxyhaemoglobin desaturations during sleep at high altitude. The aims were to compare the efficacy of theophylline andacetazolamide in normalising high-altitude SDB and in decreasing nocturnal oxyhaemoglobin desaturation.
Healthy male volunteers (n=30) gave informed written consent to participate in the study. Of 30 subjects, 22 were engaged in regular mountaineering activities in their spare time, but none of them had experienced altitudes above 3,500 m. The study protocol was approved by the local ethics committee. Exclusion criteria were females, smoking, previous pulmonary disease and concomitant medication. Inclusion criteria were normal weight (body mass index (BMI) <25) and a medical history of constant good health.
Design of the study
The double-blind, randomised, placebo-controlled prospective study was performed at the high-alpine research station (3,454 m) of the University of Berne, Switzerland. The study period (total 46 h) included two consecutive nights, and two daytime periods including the evening of the first day (6 h), the whole second day (18, 24, 30 h) and the morning of the third day (42 h). Physical exercise (except a fast 1‐h walk of all subjects to the Moensjoch hut at 3,750 m on the first evening) and drugs were not allowed.
Ten subjects were each randomly allocated to 250 mg oralslow-release theophylline (Euphylong; Byk Gulden, Konstanz, Germany), 250 mg acetazolamide (Diamox; Lederle, Muenster, Germany) or placebo (matched tablets) twice daily, starting 3 days before the journey and ending on the morning of the last day. According to experience from a previous study 7, the authors expected the dosage of theophylline to improve sleeping patterns without increased incidence of side-effects.
Arterialised capillary blood was collected at 6, 18, 24, 30 and 42 h to measure arterial oxygen tension (Pa,O2), arterial carbon dioxide tension (Pa,CO2) and pH (ABL 5; Radiometer Inc., Copenhagen, Denmark). Theophylline serum levels were measured in the morning and evening before the intake of the medication (enzyme immunoassay CEDIA® Theophylline II; Boehringer Mannheim, Indianapolis, IN, USA).
Standard polysomnography was performed with a 32‐channel polysomnographic device (Sleep Screener; Jaeger Inc., Wuerzburg, Germany) to measure sleep stages (two-channel electroencephalogram (EEG) C4‐A1 and C3‐A2 according to the international 10/20 system, submental electromyograms (EMGs), electro-oculogram), respiratory function (thoracoabdominal excursions, nasal cannulas, snoring microphone, transcutaneous pulse oximetry), heart rate (two-lead electrocardiogram) and periodic leg movements (tibialis anterior EMGs).
An experienced sleep specialist who was blinded for the administered medication scored the polysomnograms manually. Sleep stages were defined according to the standard criteria of Rechtschaffen and Kales 10, and arousals were classified following the American Sleep Disorders Association criteria 11. To avoid arbitrary assignment of respiratory events due to the sometimes difficult interpretation of respiratory signals (measurement of oral/nasal flow by a thermistor is known to underestimate hypoventilations 12), hypopnoea, apnoea, desaturations, apnoea/hypopnoea index (AHI) and desaturation index (DI) were defined according to standard criteria 13.
An episode of apnoea was diagnosed if complete cessation of inspiratory airflow occurred for ≥10 s. An episode of obstructive apnoea was defined as the absence of airflow in the presence of rib cage and abdominal movements. An episode of central apnoea was defined as the absence of rib cage and abdominal excursions together with the absence of airflow. Hypopnoea was defined as a >40% reduction of airflow lasting ≥10 s, associated with a 4% (or more) decrease in arterial oxyhaemoglobin saturation or an EEG arousal, or both. Desaturations were defined as a fall in oxyhaemoglobin saturation of ≥4% over a period of 8–60 s, the number of desaturations per hour was referred to as DI. The number of episodes of apnoea and hypopnoea per hour was referred to as AHI.
The calculated power of the study with a type‐I error of 2.5% (for comparison of placebo versus acetazolamide or theophylline) was 81.2% with 10 subjects in each group, when a mean difference of >30 events·h−1 (sd 20·h−1) was assumed. Analysis of variance procedures were performed and the least significant difference post hoc test to compare the three groups for sleep indices, respiratory indices, blood-gas parameters and heart rate. A p‐value of <0.05 was regarded as statistically significant. Values are expressed as mean±sd or as median (range).
The three study groups did not differ significantly in mean age and BMI (data not shown). Mean theophylline serum levels of the theophylline group are given in table 1⇓.
Arterial blood gases
The results of blood-gas measurements are shown in tables 2 and 3⇓⇓. Arterial oxyhaemoglobin tension was significantly higher by increased alveolar ventilation in the acetazolamide group compared with the placebo or theophylline group. In the placebo group, an increase was found in Pa,O2 and a decrease in Pa,CO2 during the study period, which was attributed to the ongoing acclimatisation process. Acetazolamide caused lower pH values, compared with placebo and theophylline (7.39±0.02 versus 7.45±0.02 or 7.45±0.03, respectively).
Sleep studies: respiratory patterns
The sleep studies of two subjects (one with theophylline, one with acetazolamide) of the second night were lost due to a technical defect. The mean recording time was 5.6 h in the first night and 6.0 h in the second night. There was no significant difference in recording time between the three study groups (table 4⇓).
The exposure to altitude induced SDB predominantly of the Cheyne-Stokes type during the night in nearly all subjects. Central apnoeas or hypopnoeas accounted for 98% of all respiratory events during sleep in the placebo group, for 71% in the acetazolamide group and for 78% in the theophylline group. The other respiratory events were mostly hypopnoeas of the obstructive or mixed type (table 4⇑).
There was a profound difference in the number of events between the placebo group and the treatment groups. In the placebo group, the median AHI (16.2·h−1, range 3–92) and the median DI (41.5·h−1, range 6–114·h−1) were highly pathological in the first night. A mild reduction in total event numbers was observed in the second night (21% in the placebo group versus 39% in the theophylline group versus 63% in the acetazolamide group).
In contrast to the severely impaired respiration during the night in the placebo group, both acetazolamide and theophylline reduced periodic breathing substantially and normalised nocturnal breathing patterns. The median AHI was <5·h−1 in both nights. However, both groups included some individuals with higher AHI, with a maximum score of 11·h−1 in the acetazolamide group and 19·h−1 in the theophylline group. Nevertheless, these maximum values were still below the mean values of the placebo group (table 4⇑).
The relative incidence of obstructive or mixed respiratory events was higher with both drugs, compared with the placebo group. However, the mean absolute number of respiratory events other than central apnoeas or hypopnoeas was not significantly different in all three groups. During thefirst night, 2.3 events·night−1 (range 0–10) were found in the placebo group, 4.5 events·night−1 (range 0–16) in the acetezolamide group and 7.1 events·night−1 (range 0–24) in the theophylline group (p>0.1).
The discrepancy between the higher DI and the lower AHI in all groups is due to the frequent Cheyne-Stokes breathing pattern. This waxing and waning breathing pattern induces periodic desaturations. However, these respiratory events do often not meet the standard criteria defined in the method section for apnoea or hypopnoea, generally due to the short duration (<10 s) of the event or to insufficient decrease of the thermistor signal (figs 1 and 2⇓⇓).
In accordance with daytime changes of arterial blood gases, basal and nocturnal oxyhaemoglobin saturation differed significantly between acetazolamide (improvement>5%) and theophylline and placebo, respectively, during the night (no change).
Sleep studies: sleep stages and arousals
When analysing sleep quality during both nights, it is striking that overall sleep architecture (including substantial rapid eye movement (REM) sleep and slow-wave non‐REM sleep) was very well preserved. A distinct “first night effect” was not found as the sleep efficiency remained virtually unchanged during both nights. The relative amount of sleep stages corresponded to normal values found in healthy volunteers in lowland studies. The only significant difference found between the three groups was a slightly reduced amount of stage‐I sleep in the acetazolamide group in the first night, in favour of an increase of stage IV and REM sleep. In spite of the high AHI, the number of arousals in the treatment group relative to the placebo group only achieved significance in the second night at high altitude (table 5⇓).
All the subjects were naive to the drugs employed in this study. In addition to the symptoms related to AMS, no major side-effects of the drugs were reported. Of the subjects on acetazolamide, 60% observed paresthesias in hands and feet and impaired taste of fizzy drinks. Of the subjects on theophylline, 70% reported heart palpitations. Nearly all subjects (including placebo) reported increased diuresis, especially during the night.
These data demonstrate that nocturnal oxygen desaturations and altered sleep respiratory patterns, reflected in a pathological AHI and DI, occurred with high frequency in healthy volunteers acutely exposed to an altitude of 3,454 m, and that the short-term administration of theophylline or acetazolamide virtually normalised SDB and reduced associated oxyhaemoglobin desaturations.
In spite of different mechanisms of action of both drugs, no significant difference was found regarding the efficacy of both drugs to reduce sleep disturbance at high altitude. Both drugs reduced SDB to a very low level.
The two drugs investigated differ in their proposed mechanisms of action. Acetazolamide increases ventilation by inducing metabolic acidosis through inhibition of the renal carbonic anhydrase with an ensuing increase in ventilation, which is reflected by higher Pa,O2 and lower Pa,CO2 values. Therefore, the observed effect of acetazolamide can be attributed to the improved oxygenation caused by hyperventilation and the left shift of the hypercapnic ventilatory response 14. According to the control theory by Khoo et al. 15, this makes the development of apnoeas after a transient rise of ventilation, e.g. after an arousal, less likely to be due to the decreased oscillations of the corrective breathing actions (hyperventilation or apnoea).
By contrast, theophylline was previously shown to increase ventilation and carbon dioxide production without affecting the slope of the hypercapnic ventilatory response 16. An increase in tidal volume (without change in respiratory frequency) was thought to be due to the competition with adenosine at some of its central receptor sites 17. In the present investigation, it seems likely that theophylline activated central respiratory receptors and reversed the hypoxic ventilatory depression 18. This resulted in a more in-phase response of ventilation to altered blood gases with consecutive reduction of periodic breathing 19, 20. The fact that the effects of theophylline observed in this investigation occurred at relatively low serum concentrations, suggests that only little activation of central chemoreceptors is necessary to stabilise the out-of-phase breathing oscillations. This finding is important when theophylline is used in a high-altitude setting, as higher serum levels could result in impaired sleep quality in susceptible individuals.
Although both drugs normalised disturbed breathing patterns, no substantial differences in stages of sleep, arousal indices and sleep efficiency were found. However, in contrast to some previous studies, sleep quality was barely impaired even in the control group 3, 21, 22. The lack of correlation between arousal indices and AHI in this study indicates that the number of arousals was a result of the altitude exposure itself and not secondary to respiratory events 23. In the second night, there was a trend to lower arousal indices with both active treatments. This is in accordance with the study of Weil et al. 5, which showed that acetazolamide reduces arousals during high-altitude sleep. As the lowest arousal index was found in the acetazolamide group, this effect may result from increased basal oxygen saturation rather than from reduced periodic breathing.
This study, therefore, provides some evidence that theophylline is effective to reduce high-altitude, disturbed breathing patterns in susceptible subjects. Theophylline could be useful in patients with known sulphonamide intolerance and in those patient groups where the additional properties of this drug, such as antiobstructive effects as well as improved diaphragmal contractility preventing failure of respiratory muscles 24, are desirable. These patient groups include individuals with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease when travelling and staying at higher altitudes.
Although acetazolamide remains the standard treatment ofacute mountain sickness and periodic breathing at high altitude, the authors conclude that theophylline is an effective alternative with possible benefits for patients with concomitant respiratory disorders (e.g. exercise or cold-induced bronchospasm) or renal disease.
- Received December 6, 2002.
- Accepted June 27, 2003.
- © ERS Journals Ltd