Copyright ©ERS Journals Ltd 2005 The role of increased pulmonary blood flow in pulmonary arterial hypertension1 Dept of Experimental Cardiology, University Medical Centre Groningen, and 2 Dept of Pediatrics, Division of Pediatric Cardiology, Beatrix Children's Hospital, University Medical Centre Groningen, Groningen, and 3 Dept of Pediatrics, Division of Pediatric Cardiology, and 4 Dept of Pharmacology, Erasmus Medical Center, Rotterdam, The Netherlands. CORRESPONDENCE: M. E. van Albada, Dept of Experimental Cardiology, University Medical Centre Groningen, University of Groningen, Antonius Deusinglaan 1, 9713 AV Groningen, The Netherlands. Fax: 31 503632812. E-mail: m.e.van.albada@med.umcg.nl Keywords: Animal model, congenital heart disease, plexogenic arteriopathy, pulmonary arterial hypertension, pulmonary vascular histopathology, right heart failure
Received: February 10, 2005
Chronic increased pulmonary blood flow is considered a pre-requisite for the induction of advanced vascular lesions in pulmonary arterial hypertension in congenital heart defects. The aim of the present study was to characterise the effects of increased pulmonary flow induced by an aortocaval shunt in the monocrotaline rat model for pulmonary hypertension in terms of survival, haemodynamics, pathology and histology. Male Wistar rats were injected with monocrotaline followed by the creation of an abdominal aortocaval shunt. Animals were sacrificed when displaying symptoms of weight loss or dyspnoea, 45 weeks after the creation of the shunt. Echocardiography identified increased ventricular dimensions in shunted rats and right ventricular hypertrophy in monocrotaline-treated rats. At similar pulmonary artery pressures, shunted monocrotaline rats displayed higher morbidity and mortality, increased pulmonary-to-systemic artery pressure ratios and increased right ventricular hypertrophy compared with nonshunted monocrotaline rats. Histological assessment demonstrated increased number and diameter of pre-acinar pulmonary arteries. Intra-acinar vessel remodelling and occlusion occurred to a similar extent in shunted and nonshunted monocrotaline rats. In conclusion, increased pulmonary blood flow in monocrotaline-induced pulmonary hypertension is associated with increased morbidity, mortality, and unfavourable haemodynamic and cardiac effects. These effects could be attributed to more pronounced right heart failure rather than to altered intra-acinar pulmonary vessel remodelling. Patients with congenital heart disease associated with systemic-to-pulmonary shunts, increasing both pulmonary blood flow and pressure, develop characteristic pulmonary vascular lesions as concentric-laminar intimal fibrosis and plexiform lesions. These vascular lesions are characterised by vascular smooth muscle and endothelial cell proliferation. In contrast, in patients with congenital heart defects and isolated increased pulmonary artery pressure (PAP), these lesions almost never develop 1, 2. The current authors hypothesise that, in congenital heart defects, increased pulmonary blood flow, in addition to increased pressure, is a pre-requisite for the development of the hallmark lesions of advanced pulmonary arterial hypertension. Animal models with an isolated increase in PAP, e.g. induced by the toxic alkaloid monocrotaline, show pulmonary vascular remodelling, but fail to display the more advanced lesions as described previously 35. The role of increased pulmonary blood flow has been explored in animal models 6. In rat models with isolated increased flow 7, 8, a moderate increase in pulmonary pressure and medial hypertrophy has been observed, but only after a prolonged period of exposure. When the additional effect of flow was explored in existing rat models for pulmonary arterial hypertension, cellular occlusion of small vessels, referred to as neo-intimal formation, was only observed in animals with increased pulmonary blood flow 911. In contrast, one recent report suggests a favourable effect of increased blood flow. In this study, rats with an abdominal aortocaval shunt in addition to monocrotaline, showed a reduction in neo-intimal formation 10. In the present study, the role of increased pulmonary flow induced by an abdominal aortocaval shunt in the monocrotaline rat model is explored in further detail via haemodynamical, echocardiographical and histopathological characterisation, with special emphasis on neo-intimal formation.
Experimental protocol In total, 39 male Wistar rats (250350 g; fed ad libitum) were housed under diurnal lighting conditions. Animal care and experiments were conducted according to the Dutch Animal Experimental Act. The Erasmus University Animal Care and Use Committee (Rotterdam, The Netherlands) approved the experimental protocol. Rats were randomly assigned to one of four experimental groups: 1) control (CON: n = 11); 2) increased pulmonary flow by means of an abdominal aortocaval shunt (AV: n = 8); 3) increased PAP, induced by monocrotaline (MC: n = 8); and 4) the combination of both interventions (MC+AV: n = 12). Monocrotaline (Sigma Chemical Co, St. Louis, MO, USA; 60 mg·kg1 subcutaneously) or vehicle were injected. Sham or AV-shunt surgery was performed 7 days later as described by Garcia and Diebold 12 under pentobarbital anaesthesia (60 mg·kg1 intraperitoneally). Shunt patency was verified visually as swelling, colour change and pulsation of the caval vein. Animals were weighed, watched for dyspnoea and sacrificed when a 15% weight loss or debilitating dyspnoea occurred. Matched rats from the other groups were sacrificed simultaneously.
Echocardiography
Haemodynamics
Pathology
Histology
In the pre-acinar pulmonary arteries, the ratio between wall thickness and luminal diameter was calculated. Vessels <50 µm usually do not have a clearly discernible internal elastic lamina. Therefore, a vascular occlusion score was calculated in these vessels as opposed to the calculation of a medial wall to lumen ratio in the larger pulmonary arteries. Occlusion was calculated in the intra-acinar pulmonary vessels according to the following formula:
Pulmonary arteries were excluded from measurement if they had a longest/shortest diameter of >2, an incomplete circular shape or a collapse of more than one quarter of the vessel wall. Muscularisation of 40 small pulmonary vessels was assessed according to van Suylen et al. 3.
Statistical analysis
Three rats had to be excluded from further analysis due to unsuccessful shunt surgery, two from the AV group and one from the MC+AV group.
Reduced growth, lethargy and dyspnoea were observed in both the MC and MC+AV groups in the 5th and 6th week after monocrotaline administration. This led to the sacrifice of all rats in this period within a window of 1 week. Symptoms appeared earliest and the most severe in MC+AV rats, leading to preliminary death in five out of 11 of these rats (table 1
Echocardiography Increased pulmonary flow due to the AV shunt was confirmed by an increased calculated cardiac output at 4 weeks compared with non-AV rats (259±28 versus 150±12 mL·min1; p = 0.002). Furthermore, an increased diastolic left ventricular internal diameter (8.52±0.22 versus 6.73±0.34 mm; p = 0.001), an increased diastolic right ventricular internal diameter (5.78±0.20 versus 4.15±0.33 mm; p = 0.001) and a significantly higher left ventricular mass (1.17±0.06 versus 0.95±0.03 g; p = 0.004) were noted in the animals with a shunt compared with animals without a shunt. Right ventricular wall thickness, an indication for increased right ventricular afterload, was increased in animals treated with monocrotaline compared with those without monocrotaline administration (1.06±0.11 versus 0.72±0.03 mm; p = 0.02). Three out of the four MC+AV rats developed a significant tricuspid regurgitant jet, which was not present at baseline, compared with none of the animals from the other groups.
Haemodynamics
Pathology Ventricular and atrial weights are shown in table 2
Right ventricular to left ventricular plus septal weight ratio increased in the MC group with an additive effect of the shunt in the MC+AV group (fig. 2
Right atrial weight correlated with echocardiographical diastolic right ventricular internal diameter measured 4 weeks after surgery (Pearson's correlation coefficient = 0.61; p = 0.02). Lung weight was significantly increased in both the MC and MC+AV group compared with control animals, with no significant additional effect of AV shunt (lung weight: 1.35±0.06 g, 1.72±0.09 g, 2.44±0.34 g (p = 0.001 versus CON) and 2.36±0.12 g (p<0.001 versus CON) in CON, AV, MC and MC+AV, respectively).
Histology
Intra-acinar pulmonary vessels (<50 µm) In contrast to the CON and AV group, increased peripheral muscularisation and luminal occlusion due to neo-intimal formation were observed to the same extent in the MC and MC+AV groups (table 3 -smooth muscle actin (fig. 3c
Relating clinical parameters to haemodynamics and vascular histopathology Rats with thoracic fluid had: 1) significantly lower body weight (348±9 versus 398±9 g; p = 0.001); 2) higher systolic PAPs (59±6 versus 38±3 mmHg; p = 0.006); 3) higher cardiac to body weight ratio (4.2±0.1 versus 3.2±0.1 g·kg1; p<0.001); 4) higher right ventricular weight ratio (0.67±0.03 versus 0.33±0.02; p<0.001); and 5) more luminal occlusion of the intra-acinar vessels (31.3±2.0 versus 11.4±2.3%; p<0.001) compared with rats without thoracic fluid. A significant correlation was observed between luminal occlusion of the intra-acinar pulmonary vessels and right ventricular hypertrophy (expressed as right ventricular/left ventricular+interventricular septum; Pearson's correlation coefficient = 0.78; p<0.001).
The aim of the present study was to investigate the role of increased pulmonary blood flow on pulmonary vascular remodelling in pulmonary arterial hypertension. Therefore, an aortacaval shunt was created in monocrotaline-treated rats. The major finding was that compared with nonshunted monocrotaline-treated rats, shunted monocrotaline rats showed increased morbidity and mortality. This was associated with increased pulmonary-to-systemic artery pressure ratios, increased right ventricular hypertrophy and dilatation, and a higher incidence of tricuspid valve regurgitation. Pulmonary vascular histopathology and morphometry revealed no additional effects of flow on the intra-acinar pulmonary vessel remodelling. These findings suggest that the effects of an aortocaval shunt on morbidity and mortality could be attributed to more pronounced right heart failure, rather than to altered intra-acinar pulmonary vessel remodelling. Pre-acinar pulmonary arteries did increase in number and size compared with both isolated increased pressure as well as isolated increased flow. The present study, however, does not allow differentiation between a secondary dilatatory effect of increased flow and an intrinsic remodelling process of these arteries as a cause for this observation.
Effects of increased pulmonary flow on pulmonary vascular remodelling Monocrotaline-treated animals without shunt, displayed increased PAPs and right ventricular hypertrophy, while morphometry revealed increased wall thickness and increased muscularisation in the pre-acinar pulmonary arteries, as expected from earlier studies 35. Interestingly, occlusion of the intra-acinar vessels was also found in monocrotaline-treated rats. These findings are in contrast with previous studies reporting that intima proliferation is caused by the addition of flow in the monocrotaline-treated rats. In these studies, luminal occlusion was not reported in the monocrotaline-treated rats without increased pulmonary flow 9, 11. Conversely, the present results are in accordance with Nishimura et al. 10, who recently described luminal occlusion in pulmonary arterioles in the monocrotaline rat model. In most of these studies 10, 11, 17, 18 a visual scoring system was used to assess the severity of neo-intimal formation in the smaller pulmonary arteries or the examination was limited to larger pulmonary arteries 9, 1921, whereas the present study provides qualitative and quantitative morphological characterisation of the pulmonary vasculature. Animals that received both monocrotaline and a shunt displayed an increased morbidity and mortality compared with all other groups. In this respect, the current results contrast with the conclusion of Nishimura et al. 10, who suggested a salvage effect of additional flow in monocrotaline-treated rats using the same model. However, in their experimental design, monocrotaline was injected 1 week after the creation of the aortocaval shunt. Studies in the authors' laboratory showed less pronounced disease development when procedural order was used from the study by Nishimura et al. 10 (data not shown). In the current authors' opinion, this can be explained by the fact that monocrotaline is metabolised in the liver into toxic, but unstable, metabolites 22. These toxic metabolites have a half-life of a few seconds or less. Therefore, they have to exert their toxic effect in the initial passage through the lungs. Increased flow by an aortocaval shunt will lower the concentration of the metabolites transported to the lung. This may explain why induction of a shunt before the administration of monocrotaline will lead to a diminished effect of monocrotaline and less advanced pulmonary vascular disease.
The nature and severity of the histological changes in the present study are comparable with those reported in other combination models of high pulmonary pressure and flow in the rat 6, 9, 11. However, the origin of the luminal occlusion of intra-acinar vessels, which is often referred to as neo-intima, is less clear. In the present study, the intraluminal occlusion consisted of cellular material. Both endothelial cells and vascular smooth muscle cells were present in this neo-intima, since it consisted of cells that stained positive for eNOS and of cells that stained positive for
Effects of increased pulmonary flow on the heart Echocardiography in rats was established as a useful diagnostic tool for the cardiac assessment of abnormal pulmonary haemodynamics, studying right ventricular wall thickness and ventricular dimensions. The echocardiographical findings of progressive right ventricular dilatation and the development of tricuspid regurgitation in the shunted monocrotaline-treated animals support the diagnosis of right ventricular failure in these animals. Progression of clinical deterioration and right ventricular hypertrophy were correlated with increased luminal occlusion of the small pulmonary vessels, indicating that the development of right ventricular failure is aggravated by the detrimental combination of increased volume load and increased afterload of the right ventricle. Taken together, the results suggest that increased morbidity and mortality in the shunted monocrotaline rats could be attributed to effects on the heart, rather than to altered pulmonary vascular remodelling.
Limitations of the study However, neo-intimal formation, a key feature in pulmonary vascular remodelling in pulmonary arterial hypertension, is induced in this model. Other models, creating left to right shunts in young animals 16, 23, 24 might have advantages with respect to affecting flow and pressure in the pulmonary arteries comparable with the situation in congenital heart disease. However, the increase in PAP in these models is moderate and, until now, they failed to display the more advanced lesions of pulmonary arterial hypertension. These lesions distinguish pulmonary arterial hypertension from other forms of pulmonary hypertension and, therefore, probably form an important clue in the pathophysiology of pulmonary arterial hypertension. Furthermore, the present study does not provide an answer to the question as to whether increased pulmonary flow induced specific vascular cell responses at a molecular level, which might explain why in congenital heart defects the advanced pulmonary vascular lesions of pulmonary arterial hypertension occur almost exclusively in the presence of increased pulmonary blood flow.
Conclusion In conclusion, haemodynamical, echocardiographical and pathological data suggested pronounced right ventricular failure to be the cause for the increased morbidity and mortality, rather than altered pulmonary vascular remodelling. Further research on the specific role of increased pulmonary blood flow in the development of advanced pulmonary vascular lesions in pulmonary arterial hypertension, associated with congenital heart defects, is needed to understand the pathogenesis of this progressive pulmonary vascular disease.
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||