Copyright ©ERS Journals Ltd 2005 Impaired pneumococcal antibody response in bronchiectasis of unknown aetiologyDepts of 1 Pulmonology and 2 Medical Microbiology & Immunology, Sint Antonius Hospital, Nieuwegein, and 3 Dept of Immunology, Wilhelmina Children's Hospital, Utrecht, The Netherlands CORRESPONDENCE: G. T. Rijkers, Dept of Immunology, University Medical Center Utrecht, Wilhelmina Children's Hospital, PO Box 85090, 3508 AB Utrecht, The Netherlands. Fax: 31 302505311. E-mail: grijkers@wkz.azu.nl Keywords: Antibody response, bronchiectasis, high-resolution computed tomography scan, IgA, IgG2, pneumococcal polysaccharide
Received: June 17, 2004
As a defective anti-polysaccharide response can exist in the absence of an immunoglobulin deficiency, a series of 26 patients with bronchiectasis of unknown aetiology was vaccinated with a 23-valent pneumococcal polysaccharide vaccine. All patients suffered from recurrent respiratory tract infections. When measuring total antibody levels to pneumococcal serotypes 3, 4 and 9, a normal polysaccharide antibody response was found in 22 patients. However, only 11 of these subjects showed a normal pneumococcal antibody response within the IgA and/or IgG2 subclass, and thus could be classified as true responders, while 15 patients did not respond in either the IgA class or in the IgG2 subclass. When analysing differences between the responder (n = 11) and nonresponder (n = 15) groups, the latter demonstrated higher frequencies of respiratory tract infections and more severe lung pathology, as revealed by the presence of more bronchi visualised in the peripheral third of the lung by high-resolution computed tomography scanning. Moreover, nonresponders needed extensive lung surgery more often in order to control their disease (number of resected segments eight versus five). In conclusion, an important fraction of patients presenting with idiopathic bronchiectasis is associated with a selective anti-polysaccharide response deficiency and this subgroup appears to represent a more severe clinical phenotype. Therefore, it can be regarded as a separate clinical entity with possible therapeutic targets. In order to identify IgA and IgG2 anti-polysaccharide nonresponders, all patients presenting with bronchiectasis of unkown aetiology should be immunised with a pneumococcal polysaccharide vaccine, and IgA and IgG2 isotype responses should be evaluated as well as the total antibody response. Bronchiectasis is defined as chronic dilatation of bronchi, which is presently best diagnosed by high-resolution computed tomography (HRCT) of the chest 1. Patients with bronchiectasis can be asymptomatic, but many suffer from recurrent respiratory tract infections, with productive cough, dyspnoea and occasionally haemoptysis. Disease severity can range from mild disease requiring only antibiotics on demand, to severe forms, which may evolve into end-stage lung disease, ultimately requiring lung transplantion 2. There are many known causes of bronchiectasis, which can be grouped into extrinsic (post-infectious) and intrinsic (noninfectious) causes. In the past, bronchiectasis was most commonly a post-infectious complication 3. However, since the introduction of antibiotics, effective tuberculostatic drugs and the widespread implementation of childhood vaccination programmes, the incidence of post-infectious bronchiectasis has dramatically decreased. At present, bacterial infections in cystic fibrosis (CF) and allergic bronchopulmonary aspergillosis (ABPA) are amongst the most frequent forms of post-infectious bronchiectasis encountered in pulmonary medicine 4, 5.
Intrinsic causes of bronchiectasis include A selective anti-polysaccharide antibody deficiency can be present in individuals with normal total immunoglobulin levels. Ambrosino et al. 6 were the first to describe this phenomenon, which was later confirmed by others 7. Therefore, currently, a selective anti-polysaccharide antibody deficiency is a well-recognised entity in the context of recurrent respiratory tract infections. Anti-pneumococcal antibody responses predominantly reside in the IgA and IgG2 subclasses. It has previously been demonstrated by the current authors that defective IgA antibody responses can be found after vaccination with a 23-valent pneumococcal polysaccharide vaccine in patients with recurrent sinusitis, despite normal total serum immunoglobulin levels 8. In addition, in the same paper, defective IgG2 antibody responses were reported upon pneumococcal polysaccharide vaccination in patients presenting with pneumonia 8. Therefore, these results prompted an extension of the study to include antibody responses to pneumococcal polysaccharide vaccination in patients with idiopathic bronchiectasis and normal total serum immunoglobulin levels.
Patient population The study was designed as a consecutive clinical attendees' cohort study, which included 26 patients who were recruited at the outpatient pulmonary department of the Sint Antonius Hospital (Nieuwegein, The Netherlands). All patients complained of recurrent respiratory tract infections caused by bronchiectasis. Twenty-three patients were female, which is a common finding in idiopathic bronchiectasis 9. Subjects were included when serum levels of immunoglobulins, IgG1 and G2 subclasses, and IgE were within the normal range: IgA 0.53.7 g·L1, IgM 0.42.3 g·L1, IgG 817 g·L1, IgG1 4.911.4 g·L1, IgG2 1.56.4 g·L1, IgE <100 kU·L1. Bronchiectasis patients with a history of tuberculosis or exposure to Mycobacterium tuberculosis (based on a positive tuberculin skin test), those with indications for aspiration or with severe respiratory infections during childhood were excluded. CF was excluded by a sweat test and/or genotyping the CF transmembrane regulator gene (two patients).
As hypersensitivity reactions to Aspergillus fumigatus can play a role in the development of bronchiectasis 10, precipitating antibodies to A. fumigatus were determined. All but two patients scored negative in this test. The two patients with precipitins to A. fumigatus did not meet the other clinical and laboratory parameters for the diagnosis of ABPA (asthma, elevated total serum IgE, positive immediate skin test to A. fumigatus, serum IgE antibodies, blood eosinophilia, increased serum IgE and central bronchiectasis 11). The respiratory tract infection frequency of each patient was carefully assessed and based on reported infectious episodes. Infectious episodes were categorised as sinusitis, bronchitis or pneumonia. Sinusitis was defined as symptomatic inflammation of the paranasal sinuses lasting no longer than 68 weeks. Bronchitis was defined as having excessive mucous secretion 12. A sputum culture was performed if possible. Chest radiography was always used to confirm the clinical diagnosis of pneumonia. Pulmonary function testing was carried out according to the standards of the European Respiratory Society 13, 14.
Laboratory investigations All patients in the study were immunised intramuscularly with a 23-valent pneumococcal vaccine (Pneumovax; Merck and Co., Rahway, NJ, USA), containing 25 µg of purified type-specific capsular polysaccharides of 23 pneumococcal serotypes (1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6B, 7F, 8, 9N, 9V, 10A, 11A, 12F, 14, 15B, 17F, 18C, 19F, 19A, 20, 22F, 23F and 33F; Danish nomenclature). Blood samples were drawn before and 3 weeks after immunisation. Serum samples were stored at 20°C until use.
Anti-capsular polysaccharide antibody assays
Patients were classified as total responders or nonresponders on the basis of their total pneumococcal polysaccharide antibody response after vaccination. A responder was defined as having a post-vaccination titre >20 U·mL1 and at least a two-fold increase for two of the three pneumococcal serotypes tested. To allow for statistical analysis, the IgA and IgG2 antibody levels to pneumococcal serotypes 4, 6B, 9V, 14, 19F and 23F in post-immunisation samples were converted into positive (>50 U·mL1) or negative (<50 U·mL1). An isotype responder was defined as having a positive IgA and/or IgG2 antibody response to more than four out of six of the serotypes tested.
Radiological classification The HRCT scans were analysed according to the criteria described by McGuinness et al. 1, Naidich et al. 20 and Reiff et al. 21. This classification system includes three categories: cylindrical, cystic and varicose bronchiectasis. Additionally, another analysis was performed, according to the criteria described by Diederich et al. 22. The major items scored in this system were as follows. 1) Bronchial dilatation as compared with the diameter of the adjacent pulmonary artery was divided into three categories: normal <110%, mild 110150% and severe >150%. 2) The luminal diameter of the bronchus as compared with the total diameter of the bronchus was also divided into three categories: normal >80%, mild 8050% and severe <50%. 4) The bronchial contents was divided into two categories: air or mucus. 5) The cysts in cystic bronchiectasis were placed into three groups: <1 cm, 12 cm or >2 cm in size. Other signs of severity of disease were recorded as either present or absent: visualisation of bronchi in the peripheral third of the lung, volume loss, pulmonary consolidation, emphysema, interstitial lines and nodules. The extent of abnormal bronchi per lobe was recorded in four categories: <25% involvement, 2650% involvement, 5175% involvement and >75% involvement.
Statistics
A series of 26 patients was included in the study. In 24 subjects the diagnosis bronchiectasis was established based on HRCT of the chest and in two patients based on bronchography.
After pneumococcal polysaccharide vaccination, 22 patients showed a post-vaccination total antibody titre >20 U·mL1 and at least a two-fold increase of two of the three pneumococcal serotypes tested (fig. 1
However, determination of IgA and IgG2 antibodies to pneumococcal polysaccharides of serotypes 4, 6B, 9V, 14, 19F and 23F largely changed this classification (fig. 2
Thus, based on measurement of the post-vaccination total antibody titre and the selective antibody response against pneumococcal polysaccharide in the IgA and IgG2 subclasses, the nonresponder group consisted of four total nonresponders and 11 isotype nonresponders. The clinical characteristics of the nonresponder group (n = 15) and that of the responder group (n = 11) are summarised in table 2
Comparison of clinical characteristics between responders and nonresponders In both groups there was a remarkable predominance of females, i.e. 11 in the responder and 12 in the nonresponder group (p<0.01). Median age was 49 yrs in the responder versus 50 yrs in the nonresponder group. No difference was observed in distribution of smoking behaviour, allergic constitution and use of antibiotics or corticosteroids. Analysis of lung function showed normal values of forced expiratory volume in one second in five individuals (45%) of the responder group and in nine (60%) of the nonresponder group. In total, nine patients had a mild-to-moderate impairment and only three patients showed severe obstructive lung disease. Statistical analysis of these results showed no significant differences.
The number of respiratory tract infections ranged from three to 12 per year. The nonresponder group showed a higher number of infections, as illustrated in figure 3
Four patients underwent surgery in the responder group versus eight patients in the nonresponder group. Importantly, the nonresponders required more extensive surgery than the responders.These data indicate that patients with a defective pneumococcal antibody response show a higher infection frequency and require more extensive surgery.
Radiological evaluation of reponders and nonresponders
The extent of areas with abnormal bronchi per lobe was determined in all available HRCT scans. In agreement with previous data in the literature, the lower lobes tended to be more severly affected, and this was most prevalent in the non-responding group (fig. 4
In 11 patients a follow-up HRCT scan was performed because of the high infection frequency. Ten of them were nonresponders. In four patients the HRCT scan showed progression of bronchiectasis.
It is shown in the present study that 50% of the patients with idiopathic bronchiectasis and normal total serum immunoglobulin levels had a defective IgA and IgG2 anti-polysaccharide response. Clinically, these nonresponders demonstrated a higher rate of respiratory tract infections and showed more severe lung pathology as assessed by HRCT scanning. Humoral immunodeficiencies, including common variable hypogammaglobulinaemia and IgA or IgG2 subclass deficiency, are well-recognised aetiological risk factors for bronchiectasis 2. As antibodies to pneumococcal polysaccharides predominantly reside in the IgA and IgG2 subclasses, it could be anticipated that bronchiectasis patients with defective anti-polysaccharide antibody responses show insufficient levels of anti-polysaccharide IgA and IgG2 upon vaccination with pneumococcal-derived polysaccharide. Selective anti-polysaccharide antibody deficiency is associated with a variable clinical spectrum of recurrent and/or severe respiratory tract infections 7, 24. Bronchiectasis develops because respiratory pathogens are not handled adequately due to this humoral immunodeficiency, which results in permanent damage of lung tissue. It is well recognised that patients with dysimmunoglobulinaemia have a defective anti-polysaccharide antibody response 8. In addition, in patients with bronchiectasis, in the context of dysimmunoglobulinaemia deficient, anti-polysaccharide antibody responses have been found upon vaccination 4. However, this study now clearly shows that an antibody response deficiency may exist even in bronchiectasis patients with normal total immunoglobulin levels. Therefore, measurement of IgA and IgG subclass levels cannot be used as a substitute for a specific antibody response estimation 25. Consequently, it is advocated that (pneumococcal) vaccination is used to reveal specific antibody response deficiencies in apparently normal total immunoglobulin subclasses.
Pneumococcal vaccination in patients with bronchiectasis of unknown cause has been carried out in several studies and the response to vaccination has been measured by determination of total antibody concentrations to a mixture of 23 polysaccharides 4, 26, 27. In all these studies the vast majority of patients showed a normal response and, therefore, it was recommended that such screening is not required 22. Our initial screening procedure for anti-polysaccharide antibody deficiency also comprised determination of total antibody levels to pneumococcal serotypes 3, 4 and 9, which represent strong, intermediate and poor immunogenic polysaccharides, respectively. When using this approach a normal polysaccharide antibody response was found in 22 out of 26 patients studied. Hence, using the above screening only, 11 out of 15 of the nonresponder patients would have been missed. The extended screening procedure for specific IgA and IgG2 antibody levels identified a significant number of nonresponders who initially had a normal total polysaccharide antibody response. Apparently, low levels of IgA and IgG2 antibodies are quantitatively compensated by other isotypes, notably IgM. Identification of the antibody deficiency required testing the response to six pneumococcal serotypes (in the IgG2 and IgA class). The failure to respond was not associated with any particular serotype lack of response (table 1 From the clinical management point of view, it is important to recognise that nonresponder patients have a higher infection frequency, show more radiological abnormalities and have more extensive lung pathology. Of note, the radiological evaluation of bronchiectasis used in this study was based on the methodology as described by Naidich et al. 20, combined with criteria formulated by Diederich et al. 22. This approach enabled the scoring of severity and extension of lung pathology. In the current series, cylindrical, mild bronchiectasis was mainly found, and only one patient showed progression of bronchiectasis on follow-up HRCT scan. No relationship was found between the clinical symptoms and disease progression on HRCT scan. This is in agreement with the fact that there is, to date, no satisfactory radiological scoring system for severity and progression of bronchiectasis 28. In the authors opinion, a sizeable fraction of patients with bronchiectasis of unknown cause can now be classified as bronchiectasis associated with polysaccharide antibody response deficiency, which might have important clinical implications for treatment. In patients with hypogammaglobulinaemia, immunoglobulin replacement therapy reduces the infection episodes and prevents further damage of the bronchi 29, 30. In this present patient group with a defective IgG2 antibody response, immunoglobulin replacement might supplement the polysaccharide antibodies, but this would require screening of batches with sufficient polysacharide antibody titres, as well as monitoring antibody levels in patients on substitution therapy. In conclusion, all patients with bronchiectasis of unknown aetiology should be immunised with a pneumococcal polysaccharide vaccine. In addition, specific antibody responses within the IgA and IgG2 subclass should be evaluated as well as the total antibody response to identify this potentially new brochiectasis phenotype.
The authors would like to thank J.C. Grutters for valuable advice during performance of the study and preparation of the manuscript. The technical assistance of M. van Schaik and secretarial assistance of J. van der Sluis is gratefully acknowledged.
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||