Copyright ©ERS Journals Ltd 2004 High altitude impairs nasal transepithelial sodium transport in HAPE-prone subjects1 Dept of Internal Medicine and the Botnar Center for Clinical Research, Centre Hospitalier Universitaire Vaudois, Lausanne, and 2 Dept of Internal Medicine, University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland CORRESPONDENCE: U. Scherrer, Dept of Internal Medicine, BH 10.642, Centre Hospitalier Universitaire Vaudois, CH-1011 Lausanne, Switzerland. Fax: 41 213140928, E-mail: Urs.Scherrer@chuv.hospvd.ch Keywords: Alveolar fluid clearance, high altitude, hypoxia, pulmonary oedema, transepithelial sodium transport
Received: October 15, 2003
This study was supported by grants from the Swiss National Science Foundation (32.46797.96 and 3238-051157.97), the Placide Nicod Foundation, the Emma Muschamp Foundation and the International Olympic Committee.
High-altitude pulmonary oedema (HAPE) occurs in predisposed individuals at altitudes >2,500 m. Defective alveolar fluid clearance secondary to a constitutive impairment of the respiratory transepithelial sodium transport contributes to its pathogenesis. Hypoxia impairs the transepithelial sodium transport in alveolar epithelial type II cells in vitro. If this impairment is also present in vivo, high-altitude exposure could aggravate the constitutive defect in sodium transport in HAPE-prone subjects, and thereby further facilitate pulmonary oedema. Therefore, the aim of the current study was to measure the nasal potential difference (PD) in 21 HAPE-prone and 29 HAPE-resistant subjects at low altitude and 30 h after arrival at high altitude (4,559 m). High-altitude exposure significantly decreased the mean±sd nasal PD in HAPE-prone (18.0±6.2 versus 12.5±6.8 mV) but not in HAPE-resistant subjects (25.6±9.4 versus 22.9±9.2 mV). This altitude-induced decrease was not associated with an altered amiloride-sensitive fraction, but was associated with a significantly lower amiloride-insensitive fraction of the nasal PD. These findings provide evidence in vivo that an environmental factor may impair respiratory transepithelial sodium transport in humans. They are consistent with the concept that in high-altitude pulmonary oedema-susceptible subjects, the combination of a constitutive and an acquired defect in this transport mechanism facilitates the development of pulmonary oedema during high-altitude exposure. High-altitude pulmonary oedema (HAPE) is a life-threatening condition that occurs in predisposed but otherwise healthy individuals at altitudes >2,500 m. Augmented alveolar fluid flooding related to exaggerated hypoxic pulmonary vasoconstriction plays an important role in its pathogenesis, secondary to endothelial dysfunction and sympathetic overactivity 13. However, recent observations indicate that this mechanism may not be sufficient to cause high-altitude pulmonary oedema 4. Active sodium transport across the alveolar epithelium plays an important role in keeping the lungs free of fluid 5, 6. In alveolar epithelial cells, sodium enters the apical membrane primarily through the amiloride-sensitive cation channels (mainly ENaC), and is then transported across the basolateral membrane into the interstitium by the ouabain-inhibitable Na-K-ATPase 58. A genetic impairment of the transepithelial sodium transport mechanism facilitates pulmonary oedema in transgenic mice 9, 10 and possibly also in humans, as suggested by HAPE-prone subjects who have a smaller nasal potential difference (PD) (an indirect marker of vectorial sodium transport in the distal airways) 11 than mountaineers resistant to this condition 12. Consistent with this concept, prophylactic stimulation of this transport mechanism with the ß2-adrenergic agonist salmeterol, at a dose that stimulates respiratory sodium transport in vitro 8 and increases alveolar fluid clearance in vivo 13, decreased the incidence of HAPE in highly susceptible subjects 12. Hypoxia, a condition universally associated with high-altitude exposure, inhibits transepithelial sodium transport in alveolar epithelial type II cells in vitro 14, 15, in the lungs ex vivo 16 and in rats in vivo 17. If this impairment is also present in humans, high-altitude exposure could aggravate the pre-existing defect in sodium transport and thereby facilitate pulmonary oedema. To test this hypothesis, the nasal PD was measured in HAPE-prone and -resistant subjects at low altitude and 30 h after arrival at high altitude (4,559 m). To gain further insight, the effects of amiloride superfusion on nasal PD were also studied in these subjects.
From June 1997 to August 2000, 21 mountaineers (six females, 15 males, age (mean±sd) 36±8 yrs) who had had at least one radiographically documented HAPE within the previous 5 yrs, and 29 mountaineers (10 females, 19 males, age 31±6 yrs) who, despite repeated alpine-style climbing to peaks >4,000 m had never developed symptoms of HAPE or acute mountain sickness, were studied. The experimental protocols were approved by the institutional review board for human investigation and all subjects provided written informed consent.
Measurement of transepithelial sodium transport (nasal epithelial potential difference)
Study design Nasal epithelial PD was measured 30 h after arrival at the laboratory and, to determine the time-course of the high-altitude-induced changes in a subgroup of 14 HAPE-prone and eight HAPE-resistant subjects, it was also measured 68 h after their arrival at 4,559 m.
On the morning before the descent, or earlier when clinical signs of HAPE-developed, postero-anterior chest radiographs were obtained and the oxygen saturation of haemoglobin was measured (with a pulse oximeter attached to the fingertip). Chest radiographs were obtained in all subjects with the use of a mobile unit (Transportable Radiographic system; Siemens, Stockholm, Sweden) with a fixed target-to-film distance of 140 cm at 133 kV and 46 mA·s1. The radiographs were analysed according to previously described criteria 19 by a radiologist who was unaware of the subjects clinical history. Briefly, with the mediastinum used as the vertical axis and the hila as the horizontal axis, four areas of the lung were assessed separately for the presence of oedema. Each of the four areas were scored as follows: normal parenchyma was given a score of 0; areas with questionable pathological findings, 1; sections where <50% was affected by interstitial disease, 2; sections where >50% was affected by nonconfluent interstitial disease, 3; and areas of alveolar, partly confluent disease, 4. With the maximal possible score being 16, any radiograph in which at least one quadrant of a lung had a score of
Statistical analysis
At low altitude, the mean nasal PD was significantly lower (p<0.01), and its amiloride-sensitive fraction was significantly smaller (p=0.01), in HAPE-prone than in HAPE-resistant subjects (table 1
At high altitude, the difference in the nasal PD between the two groups was even larger than the one observed at low altitude, because altitude exposure further decreased the PD in HAPE-prone, but not in HAPE-resistant, subjects (fig. 1
At high altitude, oxygen saturation was significantly lower in HAPE-prone than in HAPE-resistant subjects (72±7 versus 79±5%, p<0.001), and there was a positive relationship between the nasal PD and the arterial oxygen saturation (r=0.33, p<0.05, fig. 2
High-altitude exposure did not alter the amiloride-sensitive fraction of the nasal PD, whereas it lowered the amiloride-insensitive fraction by 30% (p<0.05) in the two groups (table 1
At high altitude, none of the subjects had clinical evidence of HAPE at the time of the PD measurement. Six to 16 h after the PD measurement, 13 out of the 21 HAPE-prone, but none of the 29 HAPE-resistant subjects, developed pulmonary oedema (the radiological score ranged 213; mean score 7.3±2.7 versus 0±0, affected versus nonaffected, p<0.001). In the HAPE-prone subjects who actually developed pulmonary oedema, arterial oxygen saturation was lower than in those who did not develop HAPE, and nasal PD tended to be somewhat lower than in those who did not develop pulmonary oedema, both at low-altitude (16.5±3.1 versus 20.5±9.1 mV, p=0.25) and at high altitude (11.7±7.4 versus 13.8±5.9 mV, p=0.47), but this difference did not reach statistical significance. In subjects who actually developed pulmonary oedema, there was no correlation between the radiological score and the altitude-induced changes in nasal PD.
The current authors have recently demonstrated that, in addition to augmented alveolar fluid flooding related to exaggerated pulmonary hypertension, the predisposition to HAPE is also associated with a constitutive defect in respiratory transepithelial sodium and water transport 12. The current study shows that actual high-altitude exposure further aggravates this defect in HAPE-prone subjects. These findings provide the first evidence in vivo that an environmental factor, namely high-altitude exposure, impairs fluid absorption in the human lung. They are consistent with the new concept that, in HAPE-susceptible subjects, the combination of a constitutive and an environment-induced defect of alveolar fluid clearance facilitates pulmonary oedema during high-altitude exposure. The nasal transepithelial PD has been used to quantify respiratory transepithelial sodium transport in patients with cystic fibrosis 11, 2022, and to assess the effects of over- or under-expression of the amiloride-sensitive sodium channel on this transport mechanism 23, 24. Nasal and airways epithelium exhibit similarities in membrane bioelectric properties and ion transport, suggesting that nasal PD may represent an estimate of vectorial sodium transport in the more distal airways 11. The validity of this assumption is strengthened by the recent observation that, in mice with impaired function of the amiloride-sensitive sodium channel, nasal transepithelial PD closely reflects the impairment of the alveolar fluid clearance 9. The present findings in humans in vivo are consistent with data showing that hypoxia impairs amiloride-sensitive and -insensitive sodium transport in alveolar epithelial type II cells in vitro 14, 25 and in the human lung ex vivo 16. The altitude-induced decrease in transepithelial sodium transport does not appear to be related primarily to an impairment of the amiloride-sensitive sodium channel, since amiloride superfusion had comparable effects at low and high altitude. In the alveolar cell, transepithelial sodium transport is dependent not only on its entry from the alveolar space into the cell through the sodium channels, but also on its extrusion into the interstitium via the Na-K-ATPase located in the basolateral membrane 5. The present authors speculate that in the subjects in this study, the altitude-induced impairment of the transepithelial sodium transport was related to a defect in sodium extrusion. Consistent with this hypothesis, inhibition of the Na-K-ATPase by ouabain decreases nasal PD in the rat 26. Moreover, in mice, Na-K-ATPase activity represents a potential limiting step in respiratory transepithelial sodium transport 10, and, in the rat, hypoxia decreases nasal PD 26, alveolar fluid clearance and Na-K-ATPase function 27. However, since ENaC and Na-K-ATPase work in series, one would expect that impairment of Na-K-ATPase function increases intracellular sodium and, in turn, results in a reduced gradient for Na+ entry. Therefore, if Na-K-ATPase and ENaC were the only sodium transport mechanisms, the amiloride-sensitive fraction of nasal PD should also have decreased. The fact that such a decrease was not detected suggests alterations in additional sodium transport mechanisms. Amiloride-insensitive cation channels have been identified both on the apical and the basolateral side of rat alveolar epithelial type II cells. While their exact contribution to nasal PD and lung liquid clearance in humans remains to be established, it appears possible that altitude-induced dysfunction of such amiloride-insensitive cation channels could also contribute to the findings presented here. Several mechanisms may impair transepithelial sodium transport at high altitude. In alveolar epithelial type II cells, hypoxia decreases Na-K-ATPase mRNA expression and activity 15. It has been suggested that alveolar epithelial type II cells exposed to hypoxia may release a soluble factor that inhibits Na-K-ATPase activity 28. Interestingly, high-altitude exposure stimulates the release of an endogenous digoxin-like factor, which may have inhibitory effects on transepithelial sodium transport 29. Alternatively, hypoxia-induced oxidative stress may also inhibit sodium transport 30. In the lung, sodium transporter trafficking, an important determinant of their function 31, may be impaired by hypoxia 32. In addition to hypoxia, hypothermia also impairs sodium transport in the lung 33. However, it appears unlikely that, in the present study, hypothermia played an important role, since the measurements were performed in a room kept at 1820°C and, most importantly, isothermic solutions were used for the nasal superfusion experiments. Two recent studies reported an altitude-induced increase in nasal PD in healthy subjects 34, 35. This finding, which is in contrast with the current data and all the available in vitro and in vivo data on the effects of hypoxia on respiratory sodium transport 5, 15, has been attributed to nasal epithelial dryness-induced increase in chloride secretion 35, a phenomenon that has never been shown to occur at the alveolar level. The discrepancy between the present and earlier reports could be related to the intranasal measurement site (inferior turbinate versus medial surface) 11, 18. The PD measured across the nasal epithelium correlates closely with the one measured across the more distal airways only when measured under the inferior turbinate (protected epithelium constituted mainly of ciliated cells), but not when measured at other sites of the nasal mucosa (covered mainly by metaplastic squamous epithelium) 11. It appears that in the two previous studies, no particular care was taken to locate the recording electrode in the inferior turbinate. Other technical differences in the experimental protocols for the nasal PD measurement (e.g. temperature control of the superfused solutions or averaged repeated versus one single measurement) could be additional factors contributing to the observed differences. At high altitude, the nasal PD decreased significantly only in HAPE-prone subjects. This may be related to the more severe arterial hypoxaemia in these subjects, as suggested by the positive correlation between the oxygenation and nasal PD at high altitude. Alternatively, in addition to endothelial dysfunction and exaggerated arterial vasoconstriction 2, the altitude-induced impairment of the transepithelial sodium transport may represent a new example of a pathophysiological response to the lack of oxygen in HAPE-prone subjects. In conclusion, it has been shown here that high-altitude exposure impairs nasal transepithelial sodium transport in high-altitude pulmonary oedema-prone subjects. Taken together with the authors previous data 12, these findings suggest that the conjunction of a constitutive and an acquired defect in this transport mechanism underlies susceptibility to high-altitude pulmonary oedema. The authors speculate that a similar defect could also be operational in other disease states associated with alveolar fluid flooding and hypoxia, such as heart failure and acute respiratory distress syndrome. ß-Adrenergic stimulation of this transport mechanism 12 and correction of alveolar hypoxia may help to maintain/restore alveolar fluid clearance and accelerate the resolution of pulmonary oedema, and thereby decrease morbidity and mortality in these disease states.
The authors are indebted to the participants: the Sezione di Varallo del Club Alpino Italiano for providing the facilities at the Capanna Regina Margherita; to F. Keller for taking the chest radiographs at high altitude; to L. Trueb for help with the studies at high altitude; to C. Anglada for technical assistance; to the mountain guides, A. Enzio and B. Brand; and to the Swiss Army for providing the radiographic equipment and transporting part of the material.
This article has been cited by other articles:
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||