Copyright ©ERS Journals Ltd 2003 Idiopathic chronic eosinophilic pneumonia and asthma: how do they influence each other?1 Centre d'Etudes et de Recherche sur les Maladies "Orphelines" Pulmonaires, Hôpital Cardiovasculaire et Pneumologique Louis Pradel, Université Claude Bernard, Hospices Civils de Lyon, 3 Service de Pneumologie, Hôpital Louis Pradel, Lyon, 4 Service de Pneumologie, Hôpital Arnaud de Villeneuve, Montpellier, 5 Service de Pneumologie, Centre Hospitalier Purpan, Toulouse, 6 Service de Pneumologie, Centre Hospitalier, Sartrouville, France. 2 Service de Pneumologie, Cliniques Universitaires UCL de Mont-Godinne, Yvoir, Belgium CORRESPONDENCE: J.F. Cordier, Hôpital Louis Pradel, BP Lyon-Montchat, 69394, Lyon cedex 03, France. Fax: 33 472357653. E-mail: germop@univ-lyon1.fr Keywords: asthma, follow-up studies, idiopathic chronic eosinophilic pneumonia, steroids
Received: September 16, 2002
This study was supported by grant HCL-PHRC 93-97.005 from Ministère de l'Emploi et de la Solidarité, Paris, France. Abstract
Since idiopathic chronic eosinophilic pneumonia (ICEP) and asthma are frequently associated, their possible reciprocal influence on clinical presentation and evolution were investigated.
The clinical and follow-up features of 53 cases of ICEP, of which 41 (77%) had asthma, were reviewed retrospectively. Asthma preceded the diagnosis of ICEP in 26 patients, was contemporaneous in eight patients, and developed 17±12 months after ICEP in seven patients.
Presentation of ICEP was similar in asthmatics and nonasthmatics with the exception of a higher level of total immunoglobulin E in the former group. Patients with asthma at the time of diagnosis of ICEP were more likely to remain free of relapse of ICEP (56 versus 23%) and had a lower number of relapses per year of follow-up (median 0 versus 0.24). Moreover, they were treated more frequently with long-term inhaled corticosteroids (88 versus 31%) at last follow-up. Asthma got worse after the diagnosis of ICEP and frequently required long-term oral corticosteroids.
To conclude, among patients with idiopathic chronic eosinophilic pneumonia, asthmatics have a lower frequency of relapse than nonasthmatics, possibly because of a higher use of inhaled corticosteroids. The occurrence of idiopathic chronic eosinophilic pneumonia in asthmatics is often associated with the development of severe asthma.
Airway eosinophilic infiltration is a hallmark of asthma 4. Moreover, mild blood eosinophilia is sometimes present in asthmatic patients, and its level correlates with indices of clinical severity of the disease 5. Interestingly, some but not all patients diagnosed with ICEP have a history of asthma 2, 3, whilst others may develop asthma after a diagnosis of ICEP has been made 3. Response of ICEP to oral corticosteroid therapy is dramatic 13 but long-term oral corticosteroid therapy is necessary in up to one-half of the patients because of a high rate of relapses while decreasing or after stopping corticosteroid treatment 2, 3. The need for prolonged corticosteroid therapy not only stems from relapses of ICEP but also from the development of severe asthma 3. The present study aimed to define better the reciprocal influence of asthma and ICEP, and particularly: 1) assess whether the presence of asthma at the time of diagnosis of ICEP influenced its presentation or was associated with a less favourable outcome in terms of relapses and the need for prolonged corticosteroid therapy; and 2) better determine the severity of asthma at the time of diagnosis of ICEP and its evolution thereafter. Methods
Recruitment of cases
Data collection
Selection of cases Relapses of ICEP were defined as the reappearance of characteristic new infiltrates on chest imaging, with compatible clinical features, and blood and/or BAL eosinophilia.
Data analysis
Doses of oral corticosteroids were expressed as prednisone equivalents. An obstructive pattern at PFTs was deemed present if the ratio forced expiratory volume in one second/forced vital capacity was <88% of predicted values and <89% of predicted values in males and females, respectively. The predicted values for PFTs were those of Quanjer et al. 8. Numerical data were expressed as mean±sd (as well as median in the absence of a Gaussian distribution), and compared by the two-way unpaired t-test or the Mann-Whitney test in the absence of a Gaussian distribution. Proportions were compared by the Chi-squared test or the Fisher's exact test, as required. The severity of asthma was studied by allocating a value of 0, 1, 2 and 3 for remittent, mild-persistent, moderate-persistent and severe-persistent asthma, respectively. Comparison of asthma severity at the time of diagnosis of ICEP and at last follow-up was assessed using a Wilcoxon signed-rank test. For this particular analysis, only patients with a diagnosis of asthma prior to ICEP were included in the analysis. Indeed, it was judged that in a retrospective setting, the assessment of asthma severity was difficult without knowing the required chronic therapy. Statistical significance was defined as a p-value of Results A total of 70 questionnaires were sent to the centres having declared cases of ICEP on the GERM"O"P's registry. Of these, 55 filled-in questionnaires were received from 26 centres. Two questionnaires were rejected because of insufficient data to reliably exclude a known cause of eosinophilic pneumonia. Of the 53 selected questionnaires, 30 dealt with data from patients already included in a previous study on ICEP by the present group 3.
Patients' characteristics at the time of diagnosis of idiopathic chronic eosinophilic pneumonia The mean time interval between the onset of symptoms and the diagnosis of ICEP was 31±69 weeks (median 8 weeks). Blood eosinophilia at diagnosis of ICEP was 4.61±5.11 g·L1 (median 2.99 g·L1), which represented 30.8±15.3% of the total leukocyte count. Increased levels of total immunoglobulin (Ig)E (>120 International Units (IU)·mL1) were found in 67% of the patients. The total IgE level was 499±620 IU·mL1 (median 208 IU·mL1). The cellular differential count in the BAL (n=28) revealed 54±25% eosinophils (macrophages 35±20%, lymphocytes 6±5%, neutrophils 5±6%). An obstructive pattern was found in 43% of the cases on PFTs at diagnosis of ICEP.
When comparing asthmatics and nonasthmatics prior to diagnosis of ICEP, there were no significant differences between the groups for the above-mentioned characteristics, with the exception of a higher level of blood total IgE (median 425 versus 128 IU·mL1, p=0.03, Mann-Whitney test; table 1
Characteristics of asthma at the time of diagnosis of idiopathic chronic eosinophilic pneumonia Of the 26 patients (50%) with a diagnosis of asthma prior to that of ICEP, the time interval between the diagnosis of the two diseases was 74±96 months (median 42 months). Twenty-three, 14 and eight patients were asthmatics for >1, >3 and >5 yrs, respectively. The severity of asthma was classified as mild persistent, moderate persistent and severe persistent in nine, 12 and four patients, respectively. One patient with a prior diagnosis of asthma was considered to have remittent disease at the diagnosis of ICEP. Of the asthmatic patients, 60% had already needed oral corticosteroid therapy because of an acute exacerbation of asthma.
Long-term outcome
Relapses of idiopathic chronic eosinophilic pneumonia
Asthmatics at the time of diagnosis of ICEP had fewer relapses during the follow-up compared with nonasthmatics at the time of diagnosis of ICEP. This was true whether expressed in total number of relapses (0.9±1.2 (median 0) versus 1.9±1.7 (median 1.0) relapses, p<0.05, Mann-Whitney test) or in number of relapses·YFU1 (0.14±0.2 (median 0) versus 0.42±0.7 (median 0.24) relapses·YFU1, p<0.05, Mann-Whitney test; fig. 1a
At the last follow-up visit, 65% of the patients were on long-term inhaled corticosteroids and 56% were still on oral corticosteroid therapy. The reason for long-term inhaled therapy was asthma, except in one patient for whom it was initiated for preventing relapses of ICEP. More patients with than without a diagnosis of asthma at the time of diagnosis of ICEP were on long-term inhaled corticosteroids (88 versus 31%, p<0.001, Fisher's exact test). Patients on long-term inhaled corticosteroids also had fewer relapses (0.14±0.16 (median 0.04) versus 0.51±0.76 (median 0.33) relapses·YFU1, p<0.05, Mann-Whitney test; fig. 1b The reason for pursuing oral corticosteroids was asthma in 61% and multiple ICEP relapses in 39% of the cases. There were no significant differences in the number of relapses in patients with or without oral corticosteroid therapy at the last follow-up (0.27±0.61 (median 0.07) versus 0.25±0.29 (median 0.17) relapses·YFU1). Among the 43% of patients without ICEP relapse, 81% were on long-term inhaled corticosteroids and 53% were on oral corticosteroids because of asthma at last follow-up visit.
Outcome of asthma
Of the 12 patients diagnosed with asthma at the time of or after the diagnosis of ICEP, eight (67%) and five (42%) were treated with inhaled and oral corticosteroids (5±3 mg·day1 prednisone (median 4.5)) at the last follow-up visit, respectively. Discussion The main results of the present study are three-fold. First, the study highlighted the fact that ICEP may occur in some patients as a rare complication of asthma, although it is seldom mentioned in reviews and textbooks on asthma. Secondly, when present in patients with ICEP, asthma was relatively severe and got worse after the diagnosis of ICEP. Thirdly, the presence of asthma at the time of diagnosis of ICEP was associated with less relapses of ICEP, possibly because of a higher frequency of long-term inhaled corticosteroids use in asthmatics. The prevalence of asthma in patients diagnosed with ICEP in this study (64%) is higher than reported in the literature previously 2, 3, 912, from 2853% 1. The first studies of ICEP suggested that when present at the time of diagnosis of ICEP, asthma was of recent onset (<1 yr) 1, 9, 10. However, in line with other series 2, 12, it was found that the time interval between the diagnosis of asthma and ICEP can be much longer, with a median of >3 yrs. Interestingly, as reported previously by Durieu et al. 13, as well as the present group 3, the current study confirms that asthma may develop concurrently to or after the diagnosis of ICEP. The association of ICEP and asthma may be regarded as rather logical and even expected, since both conditions are associated with eosinophilic infiltration of the respiratory tract. However, 23% of the patients in the present study never developed asthma in the follow-up. Furthermore, the authors reported the presence of eosinophilic airway infiltration demonstrated by bronchial biopsies in three patients with ICEP without a previous history of asthma 3. This parallels other conditions associated with eosinophilic inflammation involving the respiratory tract that are not associated with asthma. For example, neither IAEP 7, 14 nor eosinophilic bronchitis 15, 16 have been reported to be associated with asthma. By separating patients according to the presence or not of asthma at the time of diagnosis, one of the aims was to define two different subsets of patients with ICEP. It turned out that there were indeed differences between these two groups. However, as discussed below, the main discrepancies dealt with the long-term outcome of the disease and can potentially be explained by differences in the treatment strategies. The present study also demonstrates that asthma gets worse after the diagnosis of ICEP. Mild blood eosinophilia is present in some asthmatic patients and it is known that its level correlates with indices of clinical severity of the disease 5. Accordingly, the development of ICEP in asthmatics may be understood as a step towards more severe disease, including a worsening of the airway eosinophilic disease and the development of parenchymal eosinophilic infiltration. The severity of asthma associated with ICEP is also underlined by the fact that more than one-half of the asthmatic patients required long-term oral corticosteroids at the last follow-up visit. This compares to a 5% proportion of patients requiring oral corticosteroids in a large French cross-sectional study of asthmatics attending private-practice chest specialists 17. Accordingly, asthma in patients with ICEP must be considered to be much more severe than in the general population. An aim of the present study was to examine whether the presence of asthma at diagnosis of ICEP had an influence on the long-term outcome of the latter. The authors' initial hypothesis was that asthma could be associated with a worse prognosis of ICEP. Indeed, CSS, another eosinophilic disease with systemic involvement associated with asthma that may have close links with ICEP 3, is associated with relapses 18. Conversely, IAEP is not associated with asthma and does not relapse 7. Contrary to the initial hypothesis, the authors observed a lower number of relapses of ICEP among asthmatics at the time of diagnosis of ICEP. Moreover, more patients initially presenting with asthma never experienced any relapse. As expected, more patients with initial asthma were on long-term inhaled corticosteroids at the last follow-up visit. Together with the presence of asthma at the time of diagnosis of ICEP, long-term use of inhaled corticosteroids was the only parameter associated with fewer ICEP relapses. In addition, asthmatics at the time of diagnosis of ICEP also tended to have a lower BAL eosinophilia and a lower frequency of bilateral involvement on chest imaging. The same tendency was observed for patients on inhaled corticosteroids at the time of diagnosis of ICEP. This observation suggests that inhaled corticosteroids may decrease or control manifestations of ICEP. These findings can be put in parallel with the development of CSS in association with specific asthma therapies. It appears that in the vast majority, CSS developed during decreasing corticosteroid usage 19, suggesting that corticosteroids could have controlled CSS to some extent. Since corticosteroids represented the main treatment of the asthmatic patients included in the present study, the data suggest that the same may be true for ICEP. A role for inhaled corticosteroid treatment in ICEP has already been suggested by Naughton et al. 12 and Lavandier and Carre 20, who proposed that these would allow a decrease in doses of systemic corticosteroids in patients requiring prolonged therapy. The present study provides further evidence for a possible role of inhaled corticosteroids in preventing relapses of ICEP. The inhaled corticosteroids used by the patients in the present study were distributed among beclomethasone, budesonide and fluticasone. The small number of patients and the various doses used prevented conclusions from being drawn regarding the putative superiority of a particular type or dose of inhaled corticosteroid. Of the patients in the present study, 43% did not present any ICEP relapse during the follow-up, and thus it could be argued that ICEP has a good prognosis in a large proportion of cases. However, less than one-quarter of the patients diagnosed with ICEP have a simple outcome, i.e. without ICEP relapse and/or the need for prolonged oral corticosteroid therapy for asthma. Two findings related to putative differences between asthmatics and nonasthmatics deserve further discussion. First, though not significantly different from the nonasthmatics, the sex ratio of asthmatics prior to diagnosis of ICEP was near to one. This is unusual in ICEP, which is more frequent in females 13. The authors have no explanation for this finding. Secondly, the prevalence of smoking tended to be higher in nonasthmatics prior to diagnosis of ICEP. This may be due to the fact that asthmatics are more likely to quit smoking than nonasthmatics. However, the fact that smoking may promote the development of asthma in patients who will develop ICEP cannot be excluded. Moreover, this observation should not be overemphasised, since the number of smokers was very small, which is usual in ICEP 2, 3. The present study has some limitations mainly due to its retrospective character. Although all episodes of ICEP were treated with oral corticosteroids in all patients included in the present study, the doses and duration were not uniform and could thus influence the risk of relapse occurrence. However, there are no data in the literature to show that either the dosage or the duration of oral corticosteroids have any influence on the risk of ICEP relapse. Prospective studies addressing this issue are difficult to perform in ICEP because of its rarity, even by collaborative groups such as the GERM"O"P. To conclude, the present study confirms the strong association between idiopathic chronic eosinophilic pneumonia and asthma, and the influence of both diseases on each other. Patients that had asthma at the time of diagnosis of idiopathic chronic eosinophilic pneumonia had less frequent idiopathic chronic eosinophilic pneumonia relapses, which may suggest that inhaled corticosteroids have a favourable influence on the course of idiopathic chronic eosinophilic pneumonia. However, idiopathic chronic eosinophilic pneumonia is often associated with severe and worsening asthma, with more than one-third of the patients eventually requiring long-term oral corticosteroid therapy because of severe asthma.
Acknowledgements Members of the GERM''O''P participating in the study: France: E. Bidat (Paris), J.M. Bréchot (Paris), P.M. Broussier (Bois-Guillaume), J. Charbonneau (Montbéliard), C. Claude (Trégastel), D. Coëtmeur (Saint Brieuc), J.F. Cordier (Lyon), B. Crestani (Paris), P. Delaval (Rennes), A. Dietemann (Strasbourg), P. Dore (La Rochelle), C. Eveilleau (Brest), P. Girard (Tassin), J.Y. Jasnot (Nantes), D. Lauque (Toulouse), P. Leclerc (Sartrouville), C. Leroyer (Brest), P. Ode (Saint Etienne), F. Philip-Joet (Marseille), C. Pison (Grenoble), L. Sohier (Lorient), E. Tuchais (Angers), A. Vandevenne (Strasbourg), G. Vernet (Le Puy en Velay), P. Chanez (Montpellier). Belgium: L. Delaunois (Yvoir). References
This article has been cited by other articles:
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||