Copyright ©ERS Journals Ltd 2003 Air pollution and the elderly: oxidant/antioxidant issues worth considerationEnvironmental Sciences Research Group, School of Health and Life Sciences, King's College London, London, UK CORRESPONDENCE: F.J. Kelly, Environmental Sciences Research Group, School of Health and Life Sciences, Franklin-Wilkins Building, 150 Stamford Street, King's College London, London, SE1 9NN, UK. Fax: 44 2078483891. E-mail: frank.kelly@kcl.ac.uk Keywords: air pollution, diet, elderly, oxidant and antioxidant status, respiratory tract lining fluid
The elderly are frequently classified as being particularly susceptible to air pollution. The basis of this increased sensitivity is not known but it is likely that it is linked to age-related impaired function of the lung. However, given this uncertainty and increased impact of air pollution of this section of the community there is a need to explore the mechanisms involved. Gaseous air pollutants such as ozone and nitrogen dioxide, or many of the components adsorbed onto the surface of respirable particles, are either powerful oxidants or capable of generating free radicals. If unabated, oxidants can cause injury to the delicate cells that line the respiratory tract. Small molecular weight antioxidant defences present in respiratory tract lining fluid (RTLF) represent the first line of defence against a range of oxidants that enter the lung. The quantity and quality of the RTLF airways antioxidant network are, therefore, likely to be important determinants of the impact of the oxidant challenge on the underlying respiratory epithelium. As yet, comprehensive information on the distribution and variability of respiratory tract lining fluid antioxidant defences is only available in young, mainly healthy volunteers. Studies undertaken in patients with a range of respiratory diseases suggest that marked changes in the distribution of respiratory tract lining fluid antioxidants can occur. Information is not currently available on the impact of ageing on the respiratory tract lining fluid antioxidant defence network. As several respiratory tract lining fluid antioxidants are of dietary origin, the elderly, who often have different dietary patterns to younger individuals, may have decreased availability of important antioxidants. Given these possibilities, a better understanding of respiratory tract lining fluid antioxidant defences in the aged lung is warranted. Increasing age is accompanied by a progressive decline in lung function. This is measurable in spirometric terms as a reduction in forced expiratory volume in one second (FEV1) and forced vital capacity (FVC). Such changes are frequently accepted as the inevitable signs of the ageing process. The rate of loss of lung function is likely influenced by a number of external or environmental factors, including the quality of the individual's diet. As a consequence of the functional decline in their lungs, the elderly face the same challenges as younger people, albeit with a compromised respiratory system. Perhaps unsurprisingly, the elderly have for some time been considered to be an "at-risk group" from the impact of air pollution. Evidence supporting this notion was recently reported in the National Morbidity, Mortality and Air Pollution study 1. It was found that, amongst the elderly, hospital admissions for cardiovascular problems increased 1% for each 10-µg increase in particulates, while cardiopulmonary admissions rose 2%. It is currently unclear which, if any, of the age-related changes that occur in the lung predispose the elderly in this manner. Most elderly individuals do have reduced lung capacity and the imposition of a further reduction in lung function by air pollution may cause them to exceed a critical threshold. Likewise, as epidemiological studies indicate that air pollution is responsible for increased morbidity and mortality among the elderly with pre-existing cardiorespiratory conditions, it is relevant to question if, and how, such diseases further compromise an already susceptible lung. Clearly, increased basal inflammation exists in these patients and this would be further exacerbated following exposure to air pollution. To date, little work has been directed towards a mechanistic understanding of air pollution toxicity in the elderly. To fill this gap in knowledge, studies are required that address issues such as the lung function and inflammatory responses in aged subjects exposed to air pollution. In addition, it may also be informative to consider if, and how, diet influences lung function in the elderly and in particular, their respiratory tract lining fluid (RTLF) antioxidant defences.
The lung acts as the primary portal of entry for oxygen and various oxidants to the body. It was therefore inevitable, following the realisation that the metabolism of oxygen gives rise to a number of highly reactive oxygen-derived free radicals 2, that the antioxidant defence systems of the lung would come under scrutiny. As several of the small molecular weight antioxidants are derived from the diet, it was also inevitable that links between diet and lung function would be sought.
Interest in dietary antioxidants first arose in the area of lung disease in the 1980s, when retrospective observational studies suggested that individuals with low intakes of dietary antioxidants had decreased lung function. Studies by TOCKMAN et al. 3 and MORABIA et al. 4 indicated that dietary retinol levels are an important predictor of lung function. That is, individuals with higher retinol intakes tended to have better lung function. In 1990, SCHWARTZ and WEISS 5 reported the findings of the first National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES I), which indicated that the dietary intake of vitamin C was positively and significantly associated with FEV1. In 1991, STRACHAN et al. 6 reported that smokers with high intakes of fresh fruit and fruit juice had a higher FEV1 than those with low intake of these foods (table 1
In addition to these epidemiological studies, there are a number of cross-sectional studies, in which associations have been made between blood concentrations of dietary antioxidants and lung function and/or respiratory symptoms. In 1986, TAYLOR et al. 9 reported that chronic obstructive pulmonary disease patients with an abnormal FEV1/FVC ratio had decreased plasma antioxidant levels. In 1994, SCHWARTZ and WEISS 10 reported the findings of the NHANES II study, which suggested that both bronchitis and wheeze were negatively associated with serum vitamin C levels. In 1996, NESS et al. 11 reported that plasma vitamin C concentration correlates both with FEV1 and FVC in males, but not females. More recently, MUDWAY et al. 12 showed that FEV1 was not influenced by vitamin C supplementation in healthy, vitamin C replete, subjects. Therefore, a growing body of evidence links the intake of vitamins and pro-vitamin ß-carotene with lung function. Namely, a high intake of these dietary components is associated with higher FEV1 and FVC than low intakes, presumably as a result of improved antioxidant reserves to deal with the inevitable increases in reactive oxygen species. This scenario has been demonstrated in cystic fibrosis (CF) patients, who, because of decreased production of pancreatic juices, are unable to efficiently break down and absorb fat-soluble vitamin antioxidants, such as vitamin E and A 13. This problem, along with recurrent airway infections and increased neutrophil activity, mean that CF patients endure regular bouts of increased oxidative stress 15. Moreover, as both lung function and antioxidants status decline with age in CF patients 16, it is possible that these two events are linked, although no long-term prospective studies have yet addressed this interesting possibility. Encouragingly, short-term intervention studies have shown that ß-carotene supplementation reduces circulating markers of lipid peroxidation in CF patients 17.
Work carried out over the last decade has helped identify that oxidative injury of the respiratory epithelium is minimised by the RTLF, a thin overlying layer of fluid, rich in antioxidant defences 1921. RTLF contains enzymes (e.g. superoxide dismutase, catalase), metal binding proteins (e.g. caeruloplasmin, transferrin) and an array of small molecules including glutathione (GSH), uric acid, cysteine, methionine, vitamin C and vitamin E. Although it is appreciated that RTLF antioxidant pool sizes vary markedly in the normal population 22 there is little appreciation as to the reason for this, or the mechanism(s) underlying these differences. Indeed there is a near complete lack of understanding of antioxidant kinetics across the blood/air barrier. As a consequence of its high water solubility, vitamin C is widely distributed throughout the aqueous compartments of the body. As this antioxidant is probably freely diffusible it is likely that dietary intake plays an important role in determining RTLF vitamin C concentration. Studies in guinea pigs, which like humans are unable to synthesise vitamin C, have shown that dietary deficiency of vitamin C quickly translates to decreased blood and RTLF vitamin C levels 24. Differences in dietary intake may therefore explain, in part, the wide range of bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) fluid vitamin C concentrations reported in humans 25. In contrast the source of RTLF uric acid is not known. Several investigators including the present authors suspect that the majority of RTLF uric acid is derived from the circulation in much the same way as vitamin C. However, this cannot be the only source of uric acid in the upper airways, especially the nasal cavity, where RTLF has much higher uric acid concentrations than in the lower airways 23. De novo synthesis of uric acid within the nasal epithelium seems an unlikely source, as the concentration and activity of xanthine dehydrogenase within the nasal epithelium is low 26. It is likely that high concentrations of uric acid in the upper airways are achieved through active secretion of uric acid from cells lining the respiratory tract. RTLF is a two layer structure, comprising a lower aqueous Sol phase and an upper mucus, Gel phase. PEDEN et al. 26 have demonstrated that in the nasal cavity, RTLF Sol phase uric acid concentration is increased following cholinergic stimulation of the airways. Furthermore, they demonstrated that the increase in uric acid correlated positively with lactoferrin concentration, but not with albumin. As lactoferrin is predominately derived from mucosal gland secretions (Gel phase) this supports the contention that RTLF uric acid in the upper airways is derived, in part, from glandular secretions. Control of uric acid secretion in this compartment may therefore be closely related to mucus secretion.
Alveolar RTLF contains high concentrations (400 µmol·L1) of reduced GSH, which is
Both in vitro and in vivo experimental evidence exists to indicate that RTLF vitamin C, uric acid and GSH are consumed on exposure to ozone, nitrogen dioxide and particles 33. These reactions are sacrificial in that both the pollutant (or reactive component on the particle surface) and antioxidants are consumed (fig. 1
It has been proposed that the composition and quantity of antioxidants within the RTLF compartment might represent a significant determinant of an individual's responsiveness to air pollutants such as ozone 19. Whilst evidence suggests that good lung function is associated with diets rich in fruits and vegetables 35 there is little data linking basal pulmonary or blood antioxidant levels to individual responsiveness to oxidant gases under controlled conditions 36. It is however conceivable that boosting plasma antioxidant concentration of these antioxidants above the normal range could have a protective effect if this results in augmented RTLF antioxidant levels. In support of this contention recent field studies have demonstrated that increased intakes of nutritional antioxidants can reduce the magnitude of lung function decrements in subjects exposed to high ozone doses both occupationally (shoe cleaners in Mexico City 38) and recreationally (Dutch cyclists 39). In these studies protection was observed after prolonged periods of supplementation (75 mg vitamin E, 650 mg vitamin C, 15 mg ß-carotene, daily for 1.5 months in the Mexico City study; 100 mg vitamin E, 500 mg vitamin C daily for 15 weeks in the Dutch cyclist study) against average ozone backgrounds of 67.3 parts per billion (ppb) and 38.5 ppb respectively. Notably, significant ozone episodes were only recorded in the Mexico City study, with numerous hourly episodes above 110 ppb. Collaboration for these findings has been provided in a number of controlled chamber studies. CHATHAM et al. 40 reported protection against ozone-induced (300 ppb for 2 h, with intermittent exercise) decrements in FVC in subjects supplemented with 800 IU (528 mg) vitamin E for 14 days with a single 1 g vitamin C dose taken immediately before challenge. Notably, in this study, no protection was seen with vitamin C alone, and no protection against FEV1, forced mid-expiratory flow (FEF2575), and specific airway conductance decrements was observed. A recent (double-blinded) study examined a fuller range of response endpoints in two groups of 1516 subjects exposed to 400 ppb ozone for 2 h (minute ventilation, 20 L·min1·m2) following placebo and vitamin supplementation (250 mg vitamin C, 50 IU (33 mg) vitamin E, and a 12 oz vegetable cocktail rich in carotenoids, daily for 14 days) 41. In this study a small, yet significant blunting of the ozone-induced decrement in FEV1 (p=0.05) was observed in the supplemented group with a similar trend (p=0.06) observed in the FVC response. No protection against ozone-induced airway inflammation was reported. In this study subjects were initially placed on a restricted antioxidant diet for 7 days prior to entering the placebo, or vitamin pre-dosing period, such that their initial vitamin C, vitamin E, and ß-carotenoid concentrations were low: 34.2, 13.3 and 1.4 µmol·L1 (group means) respectively. In field studies, where protection had been observed, basal blood antioxidant levels, when measured, have been at the upper end of the normal range 38. Whilst these studies examined responses in healthy subjects, a recent study by TRENGA et al. 43 addressed whether vitamin supplementation (500 mg vitamin C; 400 IU (264 mg) vitamin E daily for 4 weeks) would protect asthmatics against ozone-induced (120 ppb for 45 min, with mild exercise) lung function decrements and following subsequent provocation with sulphur dioxide (SO2) (100 and 250 ppb). No difference between the pre- and post ozone lung function decrements (FVC, FEV1, FEF2575 and peak expiratory flow) was observed between the supplement and placebo groups. Similarly, no difference was seen in the lung function decrement observed after SO2. Indeed, overall responses actually appeared to be larger in the vitamin-receiving group.
A range of lung diseases have been linked with oxidative stress (table 2
The majority of information regarding RTLF antioxidant defences is presently derived from bronchoscopy, or induced sputum based studies, performed in relatively young, healthy volunteers, or young to middle-age patients with mild airways disease. As the antioxidant status of the blood compartment is altered in old age, it is feasible that this is also the case for RTLF antioxidants. If RTLF antioxidant defences are indeed compromised in older people, even in the absence of airways disease, this is likely to increase their sensitivity to air pollution. Therefore, a better understanding of this important host-defence mechanism is required in the elderly. Support for the concept that RTLF antioxidant defences are altered in the elderly is evident from animal studies that indicate that GSH, the most abundant intracellular and extracellular nonprotein thiol, decreases with age 52. The decrease in GSH probably occurs due to a decreased synthetic capacity, most likely owing to a decrease in g-glutamylcysteine synthetase activity. The mechanism underlying this age-related decline in the key enzyme in the GSH synthetic pathway is unknown. Studies of the airways in asymptomatic elderly humans suggest that inflammatory cell numbers are increased in comparison with younger volunteers 53. This low-grade inflammation may influence RTLF antioxidant concentrations through increased free radical fluxes in the airways. Ageing has also been associated with increased susceptibility to infection of the lung. BAL studies in clinically normal individuals of differing ages have revealed increasing cell numbers, interleukin-6 concentrations and superoxide production in older subjects. These findings have been interpreted to indicate that low-grade inflammation does indeed exist in the lower respiratory tract of many asymptomatic, clinically normally healthy volunteers of advanced age. Given this, in the absence of compensatory antioxidant changes, it is feasible that RTLF antioxidant status is compromised in the elderly.
RTLF antioxidant defences act as the first, and probably the most important level of defence against inspired pollutants. The network of RTLF antioxidant defences is highly evolved and dynamic, in that deficiencies in certain aspects of the network can be offset by upregulation of others. For example, the presence of low RTLF vitamin C concentrations triggers increased levels of extracellular superoxide dismutase, urate and reduced GSH 36. Any change in the RTLF antioxidant defence network in the elderly may explain their apparent increased susceptibility to air pollution. This may occur as a consequence of decreased vitamin intakes, increased basal oxidative stress (hence greater antioxidant demand), and probably most importantly, a decrease in their adaptive capacity. At present, only comprehensive information on respiratory tract lining fluid antioxidant defences is available in healthy young volunteers. Therefore, studies are required to determine if, and in what manner, alterations to these defences occur in the elderly both with, and without, cardiopulmonary disease.
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||