|
|
||||||||
1 Dept of Anaesthesiology and Intensive Therapy, 2 Dept of Medical Informatics and Engineering, and 3 Division of Cardiac Surgery, University of Szeged, Szeged, Hungary
CORRESPONDENCE: Z. Hantos, Dept of Medical Informatics and Engineering, University of Szeged, Korányi fasor 9, Szeged, Hungary. Fax: 36 62544566. E-mail: hantos@dmi.u-szeged.hu
Keywords: airway resistance, forced oscillations, interrupter technique, respiratory monitoring, tissue resistance
Received: January 8, 2002
Accepted July 19, 2002
This study was supported by Ministry of Health grant No. 591/1996 06.
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This study compared the values of Rrs,int provided by a Siemens 940 Lung Mechanics Monitor with total respiratory impedance (Zrs) parameters in 39 patients with normal spirometric parameters, who were undergoing elective coronary bypass surgery. Zrs was determined at the airway opening with pseudorandom oscillations of 0.26 Hz at end inspiration. Raw and tissue resistance (Rti) were derived from the Zrs data by model fitting; Rti and total resistance (Rrs,osc=Raw+Rti) were calculated at the actual respirator frequencies. Lower airway resistance (Rawl) was estimated by measuring tracheal pressure.
Although good agreement was obtained between Rrs,osc and Rrs,int, with a ratio of 1.07±0.19 (mean±sd), they correlated poorly (r2=0.36). Rti and the equipment component of Raw accounted for most of Rrs,osc (39.8±11.9 and 43.0±6.9%, respectively), whereas only a small portion belonged to Rawl (17.2±6.3%).
It is concluded that respiratory resistance may become very insensitive to changes in lower airway resistance and therefore, inappropriate for following alterations in airway tone during mechanical ventilation, especially in patients with relatively normal respiratory mechanics, where the tissue and equipment resistances represent the vast majority of the total resistance.
The accurate bedside monitoring of anaesthetised or critically ill patients involves a careful assessment of respiratory mechanics. Most of the recent commercially available ventilators are able to display the flow, pressure and volume changes throughout the respiratory cycles. From these signals, respiratory compliance (Crs) and resistance (Rrs) are also calculated on-line.
Crs is a combined index characterising the elastic properties of the lung parenchyma and the chest wall. Many diseases, including emphysema and interstitial oedema 1, alter the elasticity of the lung parenchyma directly. Furthermore, Crs is primarily affected by a loss in functional lung volume resulting from an increased closing capacity 2 leading to air trapping, or by abdominal distension 3.
Rrs is often considered to be a marker of airway resistance (Raw) 410 and is therefore, used to follow the respiratory strategy 8 and the effects of bronchoactive agents 57, 9, 10. Nevertheless, it has been well established that a significant proportion of Rrs can be attributed to energy loss in the respiratory tissues (tissue resistance (Rti)) 1121. Since the parameter Rrs is complex in nature, alterations in it may reflect pathological changes at different sites in the lungs. An increased Rrs may reflect an elevated Raw resulting from chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), an acute bronchospasm or mucus deposit in the airways. Alternatively, increases in Rti in diseases affecting the pulmonary parenchyma, such as adult respiratory distress syndrome 4, 5, 2224, COPD 20, cardiac failure 1 or congenital heart disease 25, 26, also elevate Rrs. Additionally, Rrs is often measured in such a way that it includes the resistance of the endotracheal tube (ETT), the connectors, the filters and the connecting tubing of the respirator 79, 22, i.e. the equipment resistance (Req).
Although it is evident that Raw, Rti and Req are all included in Rrs, their relative contributions have not been quantified. Accordingly, this study was performed in order to determine the airway, respiratory tissue and respiratory equipment components of Rrs displayed on a commonly used bedside ventilatory monitor. Since exact monitoring of the Raw is crucial in following the response to bronchodilator therapy, the authors also aimed to verify whether Rrs calculated by the monitor during tidal ventilation adequately indicates changes in bronchial tone.
| Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
1:3. The ventilator frequency was set to 1217 min1, and a tidal volume (VT) of 812 mL·kg1 and a positive end-expiratory pressure (PEEP) of 2 cmH2O was applied. Maintenance doses of the anaesthetics and muscle relaxants were administered as needed.
Oscillatory measurements
The set-up used for the impedance measurements during short intervals of suspended mechanical ventilation is shown schematically in figure 1
. Two collapsible latex tube segments (A and B) were clamped alternately to switch the ETT from the respirator to the oscillatory device and back as follows. During mechanical ventilation, A was open and B closed. Before the first oscillatory measurement, the lungs were inflated to a pressure of
30 cmH2O to standardise the volume history. Segment B was then opened for a few ventilatory cycles before data acquisition, in order to equilibrate the pressures in the lungs and the loudspeaker chambers. The respirator was stopped during the end-inspiratory plateau and segment A was clamped. In the resulting apnoeic period, small-amplitude (<2 cmH2O peak-to-peak) pseudorandom pressure excitations were introduced into the trachea. The forcing signal contained 30 integer-multiple components of the 0.2-Hz fundamental frequency, in the frequency range 0.26 Hz. The component amplitudes were progressively enhanced with decreasing frequency so that a sufficient signal-to-noise ratio was provided over the whole frequency range. In order to decrease the involvement of nonlinear phenomena, the phases of the components were optimised so as to give the minimum pressure excursion at the airway opening 27.
|
The recordings of oscillatory flow and pressures lasted for 15 s. Four to five measurements were recorded, and >2-min intervals of ventilation were interposed between successive measurements. The input respiratory impedances (Zrs) of the total and the lower respiratory system (Zrsl) were computed from the power spectra of Pao and V' and Ptr and V', respectively. The Zrs and Zrsl data were then ensemble-averaged separately and the data points at frequencies close to the cardiac frequency or its harmonics, and hence exhibiting large scatter, were discarded in both. The mean Zrs data were fitted by a four-parameter model 13 containing a frequency-independent Raw and inertance (Iaw) and a constant-phase tissue compartment characterised by the coefficients of damping (G) and elastance (H):
|
| (001) |
=(2/B)tangent1(H/G). The Rti and the total respiratory resistance (Rrs,osc) at the frequency of mechanical ventilation (fB) were respectively calculated as:
|
| (002) |
|
| (003) |
|
| (004) |
|
| (005) |
Conventional mechanics
The mechanical parameters were monitored by a Siemens Servo Computer Module (Type 990) attached to the respirator. The Rrs,int and Crs,int values were read before and after the collection of impedance data, and their respective mean values were applied. According to the manual of the module, Rrs,int was calculated as the ratio of the pressure drop (dP) due to the interruption of inspiratory flow to the flow before interruption; dP was determined according to:
|
| (006) |
|
| (007) |
Statistical methods
Scatters in the parameters were expressed as sd values. Paired t-tests and linear regression analysis were used to study the relationships between oscillatory and ventilatory mechanical parameters. Bland-Altman analysis 28 was performed to determine the agreement between the respiratory resistances measured by the ventilatory monitor (Rrs,int) and by the forced oscillations (Rrs,osc). A p-value <0.05 was considered to be significant.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
45 Hz, presumably a consequence of the frequency-dependent inertial distortion of the velocity profile and/or shunt effects in the central airways 29, led to systematic fitting errors. The decreases in both Rrs and Rrsl with frequency are attributed to the common tissue component, whereas the asymptotic levels of Rrs and Rrsl correspond to the airway components; the difference between them reflects the largely frequency-independent contribution of the equipment resistance. The Xrs and lower airway reactance (Xrsl) curves depart from each other with increasing frequency: the steeper increase in Xrs resulting in a resonant frequency at
3 Hz is a consequence of the substantial inertance of the equipment components.
|
|
|
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The low-frequency forced oscillation technique has been applied to partition total respiratory impedance into airway and tissue components in intubated patients free of cardiorespiratory disease 11, in normal subjects 15, COPD patients 20 and asthmatic patients receiving the optimal ventilatory waveform 21, and in healthy sedated infants 17, 18. The interrupter technique has also been demonstrated to provide separate estimates for both airway resistance and tissue viscoelasticity 23, 24, 3032. If the flow in the central airway is interrupted rapidly, the tracheal pressure responds with a transient of two distinct phases, a sudden drop and a subsequent quasi-exponential decay. The initial change in pressure results from the cessation of flow in the Newtonian resistances, whereas the slow decay corresponds to the combined process of stress relaxation of the respiratory tissues and the interregional equilibration of inhomogeneous alveolar pressures. The interruption method is therefore a potential tool with which to separate the mechanical properties of the airways and the tissues in a similar manner as offered by the low-frequency oscillation technique 12, 20. Identification of these two phases, however, requires a fast interruption and a good-quality pressure recording for further analysis, both made as close to the airway opening as possible 3032. Since the long closure time and the proximal placement of the shutter in the respirator available for this study precluded the identification of the two phases, the current authors applied low-frequency oscillations for the separation of the airway and tissue components, and the intratracheal pressure recording to identify the instrumental component.
Although the Rrs,osc and Rrs,int values were obtained at the same end-inspiratory position, there are essential differences between these methods, and the relevance of the oscillatory ratio Raw/Rti in Rrs,int is therefore not straightforward. Rti was overestimated, with the oscillatory signal being smaller than the tidal deformation because of the negative amplitude dependence of tissue resistance 16. However, Raw was underestimated because of the use of oscillatory flows smaller than the inflation flow rate, which may have exceeded the limits of linearity (this is also true for Req, and especially its ETT component). These two opposing factors possibly cancelled each other out in the total resistance, which may explain the good agreement between the mean values of <1?show=[to]>Rrs,int and Rrs,osc(fB), but they must have modified the proportions of the tissue and airway components in Rrs,int from those predicted from the oscillatory data. Nevertheless, it is unlikely that these nonlinear effects could have led to a substantially higher airway/tissue resistance ratio in Rrs,int than in Rrs,osc(fB). It should also be noted that Rrs,int was calculated from a relatively short (0.40.5 s) end-inspiratory pause, which most likely resulted in overestimation of the values of Pplateau and hence Rrs,int that would have been obtained by more accurate interruption techniques with longer (35 s) end-inspiratory pauses 32.
Although the frequency-independent resistive component of Zrs is fundamentally determined by the pulmonary system 14, 19, the chest wall has also been shown to have a frequency-independent resistive component (Rw) with a relative contribution reported to be 1037% of the total Newtonian resistance 14, 19. Since Zrs spectra were used for the estimation of the resistive parameters of the airways in the present study, both Raw and Rawl included Rw. Hence, the contribution of the intrathoracic airways to Rrs,osc and thus to Rrs,int is likely to be even smaller than the modest figure of 17.2%.
Whereas the mean values of Rrs,int and Rrs,osc(fB) were very similar (Rrs,osc/Rrs,int=1.07±0.19) and their correlation was significant, Bland-Altman analysis revealed unacceptably wide limits of agreement between these parameters. Since the difference between the total resistance values obtained by the two methods did not display any systematic tendency (fig. 4
), a random error was most probably responsible for this substantial discrepancy. Although the reasons for the inconsistency are not completely clear, temporal changes in the respiratory mechanics between the Rrs,int and Rrs,osc recordings, the poor resolution of the monitor displaying Rrs,int without showing decimals, or the noisy pressure signal limiting the accuracy of the estimation of the pressure drop following the occlusion might all have played a role.
The major finding of the present study is the very small contribution of the intrathoracic airways to the total resistance value displayed by the respiratory monitor. To estimate the specificity and sensitivity of Rrs,int in the detection of changes in airway calibre, the maximum possible change in Rawl that may remain hidden in the Rrs,int value monitored with poor resolution, as in the present case, was calculated. For a typical value of Rrs,int of 10 cmH2O·L1s, this round figure may represent any value between 9.51 and 10.50 cmH2O·L1s (a range of 0.99 cmH2O·L1s). By assuming the mean contribution of Rawl to Rrs,int to be the same as that to Rrs,osc (i.e. 17% of 10 cmH2O·L1s), increases in Rawl not exceeding 0.99 cmH2O·L1s may reach up to 67% and still remain undetectable in the monitored Rrs,int. It can therefore, be concluded that Rrs,int may become a rather insensitive measure of the airway properties, especially when the studied population, as in the present investigation, is free of airway diseases.
It is noteworthy that estimations of respiratory compliance were not subject to the problems associated with the measurement of resistance. A good correlation was found between the total respiratory compliances measured by forced oscillation and the respiratory monitor, though the latter were systematically greater (fig. 5
). This difference can be explained by the principles of the two measurement methods. Crs,osc was estimated from the oscillations applied around the end-inspiratory plateau and characterises the incremental elastic properties at that level. By contrast, Crs,int represents an average compliance for the tidal excursion between end-expiration and end-inspiration at lower mean airway pressures (Paw,mean). Both the lower Paw,mean 18 and the larger excursions 14, 16 result in higher Crs,int than Crs,osc, whereas, as noted above in connection with Rrs,int, the short end-inspiratory pause has an opposite effect on Crs,int. Since the contributions of these factors depend on the subject and the respirator settings, they may explain both the systematic difference and the random scatter in the relationship of the compliance values.
To conclude, the results of the present study demonstrate that the total respiratory resistance displayed by a standard bedside respiratory monitor in intubated patients with normal respiratory mechanics is primarily determined by the viscous resistance of the respiratory tissues and the flow resistance of the devices of the ventilatory circuit, the contribution of the airway resistance being relatively small. The present data imply that the poor accuracy of the bedside monitor may even result in the changes following a severe increase (by more than two-thirds) in the lower airway resistance remaining undetected. In the event of heterogeneous narrowing of peripheral airways, elevations in Raw are accompanied by increases in Rti 13, 16, 19, 21, which would augment the changes in Rrs,int; however, it is also possible that the alterations in Raw and Rti are independent 19. Accordingly, both in routine clinical practice and under experimental conditions, much improved bedside monitoring techniques are advocated in order to follow the changes in airway tone and tissue mechanics during mechanical ventilation.
Besides a knowledge of the instrumental resistance component, a prerequisite for higher measurement sensitivity, it is of primary importance to choose methods with the ability to separate the airway and tissue components of total respiratory resistance, such as low-frequency forced oscillations 11, 17, 20, 21 and appropriately instrumented airway interruptions 12, 23, 24, 32.
| Acknowledgements |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
E. Oostveen, D. MacLeod, H. Lorino, R. Farre, Z. Hantos, K. Desager, and F. Marchal The forced oscillation technique in clinical practice: methodology, recommendations and future developments Eur. Respir. J., December 1, 2003; 22(6): 1026 - 1041. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |