Copyright ©ERS Journals Ltd 2002 Applicability of laser scanning cytometry to study paediatric alveolar macrophages1 Dept of Child Health and 2 Division of Respiratory Medicine, Glenfield Hospital, Institute for Lung Health, University of Leicester, UK CORRESPONDENCE: J. Grigg, Senior Lecturer in Paediatric Respiratory Medicine, Leicester Children's Asthma Centre, University of Leicester, Leicester Royal Infirmary, LE2 7LX. Fax: 44 1162523282. E-mail: jg33@le.ac.uk Keywords: alveolar macrophage, bronchoalveolar lavage, child, laser scanning cytometry
Received: April 25, 2002
J. Grigg was supported by Medisearch and Henry Smith's Charity.
Laser scanning cytometry (LSC) generates quantitative information on immune receptor expression from cells cytocentrifuged onto a microscope slide. In children, the description of developmental changes in immune receptor expression on alveolar macrophages (AM) has been limited by the small number of cells recovered by bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL). The applicability of LSC to the study of AM from normal children was therefore assessed. AM were obtained by BAL of normal children following intubation prior to elective surgery. The ability of LSC to identify the cytoplasm of AM was assessed using either: 1) autofluorescence; 2) forward scatter; 3) nuclear staining with propidium iodide; or 4) a fluorescent-labelled monoclonal antibody to CD68, a pan-macrophage antigen. LSC could only reliably identify individual AM when stained with CD68. The sensitivity for detecting single whole AM using CD68 was 0.97 and the positive predictive value was 0.88, respectively, with excellent repeatability. In addition, a range of immunofluorescence parameters were generated for CD68. It is concluded that laser scanning cytometry is suited to the study of immune receptor expression from small numbers of paediatric alveolar macrophages, when CD68 is used for cell identification. The measurement of developmental changes in alveolar macrophage (AM) immune receptor expression using flow cytometry (FC) in children is limited by several factors. First, the recommended weight-adjusted bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) volume 1, 2 recovers only a small total number of AM. Secondly, normal healthy children must be recruited serendipitously prior to elective surgery, and cells must be stored for several weeks or months before batch processing. These are important deficiencies. For example, the authors have found that AM from young children are less suppressive for T-lymphocyte proliferation using in vitro functional assays 2, but the developmental changes of relevant immune receptors could not be identified because of the limited numbers of cells recovered. Animal models demonstrate changes in AM immune receptor expression during the process of normal development 3, 4 but the relevance to humans has not been validated. In contrast, the quantitative assessment of the immune receptor expression of human adult AM is less problematic, since large volumes of saline are instilled during BAL and the numbers of AM recovered and morphology are suitable for FC analysis 5. Using FC, fluorescent antibodies have attached to immune receptors on cells which are then identified as AM by their characteristic autofluorescence, light scatter properties (e.g. forward scatter) or a combination of both 6. There are, however, limitations to FC; it cannot display the staining morphology without additional cell sorting, AM cannot be restained and must be processed either when viable or when freshly fixed. Furthermore, relatively large numbers are required to overcome significant processing losses 7. To date, where AM numbers are limited or if AM morphology is required, image analysis (IA) systems such as confocal microscopy have been used 8. IA is better suited to small numbers of cells and samples can be collected, stored and then stained as a batch 9. However, data collection by IA is time consuming since all cells need to be examined by the operator and this may lead to significant subjective bias. For paediatric AM, the ideal technique should be automated, generate FC-type data, use very small numbers of cells and be able to process stored fixed cells. Laser scanning cytometry (LSC) is a new technique that potentially fulfils these requirements by combining the benefits of FC with those of IA and is built around the epi-fluorescence microscope 10. Cells are first immobilised on a conventional glass slide by centrifugation or adherence, and after immunostaining are scanned sequentially by two lasers (argon and helium-neon, emitting at 488 and 633 nm, respectively). The software recognises clusters of fluorescent pixels (pixelated clusters), these clusters being the primary "triggering" parameter for each cell. The process whereby the software identifies pixelated clusters in individual cells is called "cell capture". To date, the most common method of capturing cells is for the software to identify nuclei stained with a fluorescent dye 1113. To obtain immune receptor data from the cell surface and cytoplasm after nuclear capture, a "contour" is generated at a fixed distance from the nuclear perimeter. Fluorescent data are then generated within this contour. An alternative method of cell capture is to use the "intrinsic" properties of cells such as forward scatter 14 or autofluorescence. In these circumstances the software draws a contour around the entire cell, and the cytoplasm is assumed to be anything within this contour. An additional peripheral contour is therefore not necessary. LSC has successfully been used to examine the phenotype of many cell types including blood leukocytes 15 and eosinophils and bronchial epithelial cells in sputum 11, but has not been used to study the AM immune phenotype. LSC may be ideally suited to the study of paediatric AM. First, AM can be stored as cytospins and antigens identified using fluorescent-labelled monoclonal antibodies in batches. Second, the fluorescent intensity of AM can be automatically measured in a few minutes using as little as a 1,000 cells. Therefore, the applicability of LSC to the study of paediatric AM was assessed here. The criteria for a successful scan were defined as: 1) the accurate identification of the entire cytoplasm of individual AM; 2) the ability to compensate for groups of AM that are adherent to each other; and 3) the generation of fluorescence intensity data from the cytoplasm of individual AM. The standard FC-derived techniques of forward scatter and autofluorescence were used for identifying AM, followed by the standard LSC technique of nuclear capture after staining. In addition, a novel method of AM capture was used whereby individual AM were captured after staining with a pan-macrophage marker (CD68).
Study subjects Healthy children undergoing elective surgical procedures were recruited to this study. Children were excluded for any of the following reasons: congenital heart disease, ongoing chronic pulmonary pathology, preterm delivery requiring ventilation, or symptoms suggestive of a lower respiratory tract infection in the past 6 weeks. This study had approval from the ethics committee and written informed consent was obtained from the parents of all children participating in the study. Where appropriate verbal consent was also obtained from the child.
Study design
Methods
Processing of samples
Capture using autofluorescence and forward scatter
Capture using nuclear staining
Capture using a pan-macrophage monoclonal antibody
Laser scanning cytometry During scanning, images of the area being scanned were randomly selected and displayed on the data display window and inspected visually. This window shows pixelated areas and the presence of software-generated contours. This enables an assessment of whether contours have appropriately identified single AM, or have inappropriately characterised debris or clumps of cells as individual AM with a single contour, or even failed to detect and hence contour around AM. For each child a minimum of three data display windows were examined. AM were identified by the operator according to either the nuclear or cell size and contour shape and the following parameters were calculated: 1) the proportion of pixelated clusters that were morphologically single AM and were contoured around (sensitivity), and 2) the proportion of contours associated with pixelated clusters that were morphologically single AM (positive predictive value). For AM stained with CD68, a qualitative assessment of specificity and negative predictive value for the sample was made by comparing the amount of pixelated clusters contoured around on the isotypic control slide compared to the CD68 stained slide. The variation in repeated measurements on the same subject (repeatability) was determined in AM from three randomly selected children. Two sets of slides obtained from a single sampling procedure and stored in an identical manner were immunostained with CD68 on two separate occasions and then scanned on the same LSC by the same observer each within 48 h of immunostaining. After imaging, a presumed population of single AM were selected according to homogeneity and contour area from the software produced graphs of contour area versus pixel intensity. These "cells" were then displayed using the "relocation" feature on the software. For each sample, once scanning was recommenced, the first 36 contoured pixelated clusters that were within the selected area were visualised and the positive predictive value of the test for selecting single AM was calculated. This determined whether selecting a homogeneous population of cells with similar contour size would exclude debris or clumps of cells that had been inappropriately contoured around and increase the positive predictive value of the test for selecting single cells. To determine whether it was possible to obtain fluorescent data within the contours, the integrated fluorescence was determined for each of the fluorochromes used. The integrated fluorescence for the active sensor is the background-corrected sum of the pixel values within the data contour (equivalent to FC-integrated fluorescence). The integrated fluorescence was corrected for contour area.
Confocal microscopy
Statistics
Twenty-eight children were studied (11 females) with an age range 0.114.1 yrs. The baseline BALF cell data for these children are given in table 1
Capture after nuclear staining by PI did select nucleated cells. However, perimeter contours frequently overlapped into neighbouring cells because of the many eccentrically placed nuclei. In addition, multiple contours were frequently produced for each cell, as a result of double nuclear profiles (fig. 2
AM were successfully contoured around using CD68. The primary antibody was specific for the CD68 antigen on AM, as shown by the lack of pixelated clusters on slides stained with an appropriate isotypic control (fig. 3
Most cells were contoured around individually but a few were clumped and hence contoured around as clumps. The positive predictive value for detecting single CD68-stained AM was 0.88 (IQR 0.790.99) and the sensitivity was 0.97 (IQR 0.921.00). The repeatability coefficient for positive predictive value was 0.22, and for sensitivity was 0.05.
A population of CD68-stained AM was selected as probably being single by their contour size and homogeneity (fig. 6a
Since the CD68 monoclonal antibody was bound to the CD68 antigen it could be used as an example of staining for an immune receptor, as well as a contouring feature. FC-type data was generated for all children and corrected for contour area. The median integrated fluorescence for CD68 immunostained AM was 7,725 (IQR 6,7609,635) arbitrary units.
This study reports, for the first time, a way of studying stored paediatric AM using the LSC. Contouring around the macrophage-specific cellular antigen CD68 is a sensitive and specific technique for detecting AM, with excellent test retest repeatability for sensitivity. The advantages of this technique are three-fold. First, the AM is completely contoured around allowing specific cellular or surface antigens to be further studied without the need for a software generated peripheral contour, as the authors have demonstrated with CD68. Second, AM can be easily discriminated from other cell populations within the BALF sample. Third, most cells are contoured around singly; those that are contoured around as clumps can be easily excluded according to contour size.
The two previously reported methods for detecting cells using the LSC involve either staining the nucleus with a nucleic acid dye 1113 or contouring according to scatter properties 14. Nuclear contouring has been successfully employed for cells with single nuclear profiles and can discriminate different cell populations in peripheral blood according to the nuclear size and density of chromatin condensation 12. The nucleus of the AM however is a less attractive cell localising and contouring parameter since AM are large cells (1020 µm diameter) 20 with large eccentrically placed nuclei that are often horseshoe shaped and frequently appear bi- or even multi-nucleated when flattened on cytospins 21. When the nucleus is used as the triggering parameter, the software often identifies binucleated cells as two separate AM. Furthermore, AM have a high propensity to homotypically aggregate 22 and contours from neighbouring nuclei frequently overlap (fig. 2 Adult AM (especially those obtained from smokers) are intensely autofluorescent and this, combined with their intrinsic forward scatter properties, have allowed them to be easily identified by FC 7. AM sampled from young rats are much less autofluorescent than those sampled from older animals 24 and this may explain the weak autofluorescent properties of the paediatric samples. In addition, the process of storing cells first by applying centrifugal force, then fixing and freezing cells undoubtedly causes leaching of natural fluorochromes from cells 25, as well as altering AM morphology 26 and thus their forward scatter properties. For these reasons AM cannot be easily identified by these "intrinsic" properties. Light scatter has successfully been used as the LSC contouring parameter on live lymphocyte preparations 14 adherent to the slide, and the possibility for exploiting the forward scatter and autofluorescent properties of live AM requires further study before these can be excluded as useful contouring parameters.
What are the limitations of the present study? First, the accepted gold standard for determining the presence and intensity of cellular and surface antigens is currently FC. Ideally any new technique should be compared against this gold standard. Unfortunately, a direct comparison with FC was not made as many of the samples, especially from infants, contained insufficient cells to process them using both techniques. Second, although LSC and confocal microscopy confirm the absence of background staining and hence no contouring around cells which were not AM, it is possible that some AM were CD68 negative and not detected. Reports suggest that this accounts for To obtain data on other immune receptors, dual staining with CD68 and the receptor of interest will be necessary. One potential disadvantage of LSC, and indeed FC when dual staining, is the problem of "spill-over" of one fluorochrome into a neighbouring PMT that is being used to detect a different fluorochrome (i.e. "spectral overlap"). For a fluorochrome to be a useful contouring parameter there has to be minimal spill-over into neighbouring PMT so that the presence and intensity of the antigens under test can be studied. In order to avoid spectral overlap the authors suggest using a fluorochrome such as Alexa Fluor 633 as the contouring parameter since it is excited by the HeNe laser at 633 nm and emits at a wavelength of 670 nm far beyond the detection parameters of the other PMTs. These dyes also have the benefits of low fluorescence quenching upon binding to proteins and hence can be stored for up to 48 h with minimal bleaching. However, one disadvantage of Alexa 633 is that it is not visible to the naked eye and hence an assessment of staining using standard immunofluorescence is not possible. Therefore, the authors also immunostained some slides with R-phycoerythrin, which is excited by the argon laser and detected by the orange PMT and can be viewed with the naked eye. This detects fluorescent spectra close to that of the green and far-red PMT. The degree of compensation required for spill-over into these neighbouring PMT (compensation factor) was tested. For orange spill-over into green the compensation factor was 0.03% and for orange into far red it was 0.02% (data not shown) thus making this an acceptable contouring fluorochrome.
To conclude, laser scanning cytometry is suited to the study of paediatric alveolar macrophages since it uses very small numbers of cells (
The authors would like to thank AstraZeneca Research and Development Discovery Bioscience (Loughborough, Charnwood, UK) for use of their laser scanning cytometer and the confocal microscope.
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||