|
|
||||||||
Depts of 1 Internal Medicine, 2 Biochemistry, 3 Microbiology, 4 Preventive Medicine and Epidemiology, Vall d'Hebron General Hospital, Barcelona, Spain
CORRESPONDENCE: J. Alegre, Juan de Garay 19, 3° 1a, 08041, Barcelona, Spain. Fax: 34 32844234. E-mail: 18502jam@comb.es
Keywords: myeloperoxidase, parapneumonic pleural effusions
Received: June 13, 2000
Accepted September 5, 2001
This work was financed in part by a Fondo de Investigacion Sanitaria grant (96/0977).
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Seventy patients aged >18 yrs with PPE (36 complicated and 34 noncomplicated) were studied after admission to a tertiary referral teaching hospital. MPO concentration was measured in plasma and pleural fluid using a double-antibody competitive radioimmunoassay.
The concentrations of MPO in complicated and noncomplicated PPE were compared using a Mann-Whitney U-test and multiple logistic regression models were used to predict the odds that an effusion was complicated. MPO pleural-fluid concentrations were significantly higher in complicated than in noncomplicated PPE. After excluding purulent effusions, pleural-fluid MPO was the marker that best differentiated between the two types of PPE: the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve was 0.912, the sensitivity was 87.5% and the specificity was 85.1% at a cut-point limit of 3.000 µg·L1.
The authors concluded that the concentration of pleural-fluid myeloperoxidase helps to differentiate between nonpurulent complicated and noncomplicated parapneumonic pleural effusions.
Parapneumonic pleural effusions (PPE) are found in 2075% of patients hospitalized with moderate-to-severe community-acquired pneumonia 1. The formation of a PPE consists of three stages: exudative, fibrinopurulent and fibrous 2. The clinical consequences of this evolution allow PPE to be divided into complicated and noncomplicated types. Therefore, PPE is not a single entity, but represents a progression in which purulent, complicated PPE is the final stage 3. These parapneumonic effusions are a challenge to clinicians attempting to determine whether the effusion will respond to antibiotic therapy alone or whether the patient requires pleural drainage to manage an established empyema or prevent an empyema from forming. Proper assessment is vital because failure to initiate prompt and effective drainage when indicated increases the morbidity rates associated with pulmonary infection 4. It is important, therefore, to discriminate as accurately and as early as possible between patients with parapneumonic effusions who are likely to respond to antibiotics alone and those who require pleural-fluid drainage 5.
It is widely accepted that polymorphonuclear cells play a key role in the acute inflammatory response to bacterial infection. Neutrophils participate in the inflammatory response through the release of peptides and proteases 6. Polymorphonuclear elastase (PMN-E), a protease that originates from azurophil granules of the polymorphonuclear leukocytes (neutrophils) in response to the release of inflammatory mediators, stands out among these 7. The value of pleural-fluid PMN-E in the differentiation between infective and noninfective effusions has recently been established 8. Myeloperoxidase (MPO) is a protein responsible for the peroxidase activity characteristic of the azurophilic granules and is essential for the oxidative mechanism of the phagocytes. MPO and reduced nicotinamide-adenine dinucleotide phosphate (NADP-H) oxidase are the main proteins that participate in oxidative-type microbicidal activity 9. Increased concentrations of MPO have been reported in various inflammatory processes 1012. The authors previously detected higher levels of pleural-fluid MPO in complicated bacterial effusions than in noninfective effusions 13.
The criteria currently used for pleural drainage in the treatment of PPE are based on findings such as acid pH and purulent-appearing fluid, signs of an already advanced phase of infection 14, 15. Measurements of pH are, however, dependant on the mode of sample carriage and delay in measurement 16. A fluid glucose value <40 mg·dL1 or a located hydogenase (LDH) value >1,000 IU·L1 has also been used in the early diagnosis of complicated PPE 3, although the development of pleural thickening in the evolution of complicated PPE is not unusual 17, 18. In view of the persistence of local complications a prospective study, to evaluate whether pleural-fluid MPO concentration might be useful for early differentiation between complicated and noncomplicated PPE, was performed.
| Patients and methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Seventy patients with PPE were enrolled in the study. Thirty-six had complicated PPE (51.5%) and the remaining 34 had noncomplicated PPE (48.5%). Of the patients with complicated PPE (mean age 56 yrs, 89% males), 21 (58%) had positive cultures and 20 (55%) purulent pleural effusion. Sixty-seven per cent had other illnesses (chronic bronchitis, diabetes mellitus or chronic hepatic disease) and 28% had received antibiotics previously. The most frequently used antibiotic during hospitalization was co-amoxyclavulanic acid. All the patients with complicated PPE were treated by pleural drainage, six received intrapleural urokinase and three had pleural decortication. Complications consisting of pleural thickening and pleural loculation were recorded in 31 patients (86%).
The 34 patients with noncomplicated PPE had a mean age of 54 yrs and 70.5% were males. In 59%, other illnesses were present (chronic bronchitis, diabetes mellitus, chronic hepatic disease) and 35% had received antibiotics previously. During hospitalization, the most frequently used antibiotic combinations (88%) were cephalosporins plus macrolides. Complications, including loculations and pleural thickening, were present in 35% of patients. None of the patients were taking either corticosteroids or nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs.
Biochemical, cytological and bacteriological methods
Biochemical measurements were carried out using a Hitachi 919 automatic analyser (Boehriger Mannheim, GMbH, Mannheim, Germany), using the method of Biuret for proteins, hexokinase for glucose, and pyruvate-to-lactate reduction at 37° for LDH.
For determination, pH pleural fluid was collected directly into a heparinized blood-gas syringe and was maintained anaerobically. The syringe containing the pleural fluid was immediately placed on ice and transferred to the laboratory. Pleural-fluid pH was measured within 20 min after thoracocentesis using a selective pH electrode (Chiron Diagnostics 860; Ciba Corning Diagnostics Corp., Medfield, MA, USA).
For PMN-E and MPO determinations, samples were collected in ethylene diamine tetra-acetic acid and plasma or pleural-fluid supernatants were separated within the first hour. PMN-E was determined by an immunoactivation method (IMAC, Merck kGaA, Darmstad, Germany) that measures free and
1 proteinase inhibitor-bound PMN-E19. The between-run imprecision for a mean value of 134 µg·L1 was 8.9% (n=20). MPO was measured by double-antibody competitive radioimmunoassay (Pharmacia Diagnostics, Uppsala, Sweden). The between-run imprecision for a mean value of 450 mg·L1 was 4.8% (n=20). Lysozyme was measured by means of a turbidimetric method.
Total white blood cell counts were carried out with a Coulter®-s-Plus IV Counter Izasa, Spain. To differentiate between leukocytes, the sample was centrifuged (Cytospin® 2, Shandon Southern Products Ltd, UK) at 2,000 revolutions per minute for 8 min, and the preparation obtained was stained with May-Grunwald-Giemsa.
For microbiological studies, pleural-fluid samples were extracted by thoracocentesis under aseptic conditions and sent to the bacteriology laboratory in a sterile tube and an anaerobic blood culture vial (Bactec NR 660 system; Becton Dickinson, USA). Gram and Ziehl-Neelsen stains were carried out and cultures were performed in conventional media for aerobic and anaerobic micro-organisms, fungi, legionella and mycobacteria. Pneumococcal antigen was detected by means of the coagglutination technique (Phedebact Pneumococcus test; Boule Diagnostics, Huddinge, Sweden).
Statistical analysis
Because of the presence of extreme values among the pleural-fluid biochemical variables, the Mann-Whitney U-test was used to compare their distribution in complicated and noncomplicated PPE. Multiple logistic regression models were used to predict the odds that an effusion was complicated.
The validity of the predictions derived from the multiple logistic regression models was assessed. Each type of misclassification was evaluated according to its cost (weights were 2 for misclassifying a complicated PPE as noncomplicated, 1 for misclassifying a noncomplicated PPE as complicated, and 0 for correct predictions). The cut-point with the highest global value was selected according to this evaluation. The binomial distribution was used to estimate the 95% confidence intervals (CI) for sensitivity and specificity. To assess the diagnostic accuracy of MPO as an early marker in the diagnosis of complicated PPE, the statistical analysis was repeated after excluding purulent effusions.
The agreement between pleural pH<7.2, pleural glucose <40 mg·dL1, pleural LDH>1,000 IU·L1 and a pleural MPO value greater than the suggested cut-point was assessed. The kappa statistic was used to adjust the observed agreement for chance; its standard error was used to test the hypothesis that the underlying value of kappa was zero 20. This study evaluated whether a difference of 0.3 between plasma and pleural pH differentiated between complicated and noncomplicated PPE. The Mann-Whitney U-test was used to evaluate the associations between pH, glucose, LDH, MPO or polymorphonuclear leukocyte count in pleural fluid and later loculation of PPE. The study was approved by the Clinical Assay Committee.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
|
|
|
Among the 36 PPE classified as complicated by the conventional biochemical criteria, 34 (94%) had pleural pH<7.20 or pleural glucose<40 mg·dL1 or pleural LDH>1,000 IU·L1 and MPO>3.000 µg·L1 and none had pH<7.20 and MPO<3.000 µg·L1. The other two complicated PPE were classified as such by positive pleural-fluid culture, with pleural pH>7.20 and pleural MPO<3.000 µg·L1. Serratia marcescens and Crytococcus neoformans were isolated from pleural fluid in these patients.
In the 34 noncomplicated PPE, 28 (82%) had a pH>7.20 or glucose>40 mg·dL1 or LDH<1,000 IU·L1 and MPO<3.000 µg·L1. On the basis of biochemical criteria for classifying complicated PPE (pleural pH<7.20 or pleural glucose<40 mg·dL1), pleural MPO identified five more PPE as being complicated and four of these had pleural LDH>1,000 IU·L1. Follow-up radiography on three of these five patients showed the presence of pleural thickening.
Associations between polymorphonuclear count and biochemical markers in pleural fluid and later loculation or pleural thickening were statistically significant for pH (p=0.001), glucose (p=0.048), MPO (p=0.026) and polymorphonuclear leukocyte count (p=0.013).
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The biochemical characteristics of pleural fluid are the indices most often used to identify complicated PPE, and pH is one of the most widely used guides to indicate the need for pleural drainage in this condition 1, 14, 24, 25. The importance of the combination of biochemical indices (pH<7.2, glucose<40 mg·dL1, LDH>1,000 IU·L1) in the diagnosis of PPE has been stressed previously 3.
It is well recognized that accurate pH determination requires strict anaerobic extraction and rapid transport and analytical techniques. These conditions, however, are not always fulfilled 16. Physicians handle samples for pleural-fluid pH determination in a variety of ways 26, such as collection in a large syringe and transfer to a heparinized syringe for pH assessment 27, and with varying use of local anaesthesia 28.
In a recently published meta-analysis investigating the ability of the commonly used markers to identify complicated PPE requiring drainage, the results for fluid pH showed an area under the ROC curve of 0.92 and, after excluding purulent effusions from the analysis, 0.89. Pleural-fluid pH had a relatively high diagnostic accuracy, greater than that of pleural-fluid glucose and LDH, for discriminating between complicated and noncomplicated parapneumonic effusions 21.
The present study identified pleural-fluid MPO, with a sensitivity of 94.1% and a specificity of 85.1% at the 3.000 µg·L1 cut-point, as the best index for discriminating between complicated and noncomplicated PPE. After excluding purulent effusions, pleural-fluid MPO was still the marker that best differentiated between the two types of PPE, with a sensitivity of 87.5% and a specificity of 85.1% at a cut-point limit of 3.000 µg·L1. The differences in mean levels of MPO between a previous report 13 and this study, are due to the inclusion of four additional cases in each subgroup of PPE. The aim of the previous report was to study whether interleukin (IL)-8 was produced in the pleural space and its relation to the neutrophil activation state in infected pleural fluid.
It is recognized that during the inflammatory process, leukocytes release intracellular constituents, such as bactericidal permeability-increasing protein, defensins, lysozyme, cationic proteins, lactoferrin and zinc-binding proteins 9. MPO is the most abundant protein of the neutrophils and catalyzes the conversion of hydrogen peroxide and chloride into hypochloride 29, an essential component of the oxygen-dependant microbicidal system, with NADPH oxidase of neutrophils and monocytes 30. An increased MPO concentration is an indirect, but clear indication of MPO release by an inflammatory process. MPO, as a marker of inflammation, has been measured to distinguish otitis media, chronic sinusitis, chronic bronchitis and peritonitis of bacterial origin 1012, in which excellent correlations have been observed with levels of IL-8, a cytokine involved not only in chemotaxis, but also in neutrophil activation.
The demonstration of the discriminatory role of pleural MPO, after excluding purulent PPE, together with the significant relations between pleural MPO and standard biochemical markers and between pleural levels of neutrophilic markers and pleural complications of PPE, suggest that MPO may be a useful tool for the management of patients with PPE. Correct differentiation between a complicated and noncomplicated PPE is associated with better prognosis 5. Late pleural drainage can result in complications, leading to decreased pulmonary function. Moreover, there may be a greater need for pleural thrombolytic agents and pleural decortication 4, 5, 15, implying increased hospital stay and healthcare costs 5.
Significant pleural complications still occur when using classical criteria to indicate pleural drainage, i.e. the presence of purulent pleural fluid, microorganisms on Gram-stain and/or positive culture and pleural pH<7.20 and/or pleural glucose<40 mg·100 mL1 in the context of a clinical and radiological process 17, 18. There are three situations in which the usefulness of pH is subject to controversy: 1) in cases where pH is between 77.2, there is no consensus as to the ideal approach to take and opinions range from the use of conservative treatment, i.e. empirical therapy with broad-spectrum antibiotics, to early thoracic drainage; 2) in cases involving technical difficulties in the extraction, transport or processing of the samples; and 3) when the value of pH results is questionable because patients received antibiotic treatment before thoracocentesis. Determination of pleural-fluid MPO concentration could be particularly useful in these borderline or difficult cases. In the present study, measurement of pleural MPO permitted early detection of five patients with complicated PPE, four of whom had pleural LDH>1,000 IU·L1. Subsequently, complications consisting of pleural thickening were detected in three of these patients and two of them also had pleural LDH>1,000 IU·L1. In addition, it was found that the handling of samples was comparatively simple and did not require the strict conditions required for accurate pH determination 16, 26, 27.
The present results indicate that pleural-fluid myeloperoxidase concentration is a good discriminant between nonpurulent complicated and noncomplicated parapneumonic pleural fluid. Myeloperoxidase measurement could help in the management of this condition, since it is less affected by technical variation than pH determination. Pleural-fluid myeloperoxidase concentrations >3.000 µg·L1 are highly suggestive of complicated parapneumonic pleural effusion.
| Acknowledgements |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
J. M. Porcel, M. Vives, and A. Esquerda Tumor Necrosis Factor-{alpha} in Pleural Fluid: A Marker of Complicated Parapneumonic Effusions Chest, January 1, 2004; 125(1): 160 - 164. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |