Copyright ©ERS Journals Ltd 2001 Physiological responses of the airway wall and lung in hyperresponsive pigs1 Dept of Physiology, University of Western Australia and 2 Dept of Pathology, Murdoch University, Perth, Western Australia, Australia CORRESPONDENCE: D.J. Turner, Dept of Physiology, University of Western Australia, Nedlands, WA 6907, Australia. Fax: 61 893801025 Keywords: acetylcholine, airway hyperresponsiveness, allergen, bronchi, smooth muscle
Received: March 20, 2001
This work was supported by the National Health and Medical Research Council of Australia.
Airway hyperresponsiveness (AHR) might be driven by mechanisms inherent to the airway wall, and/or by factors arising from outside the airways. A porcine model of allergen-induced AHR was utilized to investigate physiological responses in intact airways in vitro and their contribution to responsiveness in vivo. Responsiveness to acetylcholine (ACh) was measured in eight ovalbumin (OA)-sensitized/challenged pigs (tests) and eight saline-challenged controls. In vivo responsiveness to ACh was determined from pulmonary resistance (RL). In vitro responsiveness to ACh was determined from airway pressure in isovolumic bronchial segments, after exposure via the adventitial or the luminal surface. Test pigs had lung (255±26% increase in RL, p<0.0001) and skin responses to OA, and AHR to ACh (p<0.0001). In vitro, test bronchi were less sensitive than controls to ACh applied to the airway adventitia (negative log of the ACh concentration producing half the maximum response (pD2)=4.18 and 4.58 respectively, p<0.01), but not the lumen. Test bronchi had an increased amount of smooth muscle normalized for airway size versus controls (p<0.05). Maximum responses to lumenal ACh in vitro showed a weak positive correlation with maximum changes to ACh in vivo (r=0.599, p=0.05). This study concludes that the effect of antigen challenge on bronchial responsiveness varies with the route of exposure to acetylcholine. In vitro responses to lumenal acetylcholine are increased despite a possible reduction in responsiveness of airway smooth muscle. Responsiveness of the bronchial wall only partially explains responsiveness of the lungs in vivo. Despite the central role of airway narrowing in the response of the lung to provocative stimuli, its importance in airway hyperresponsiveness (AHR) has not been established. Since smooth muscle contraction is a major determinant of airway diameter, one proposal has been that AHR is due to altered contractile behaviour of airway smooth muscle (ASM). Studies in allergic animal models indicate that ASM contraction might be increased 13, while the responses of smooth muscle isolated from asthmatics are variable 4, 5. In vivo, ASM is subject to additional factors arising from outside the airway, such as load from parenchymal tethering 6. Some studies suggest that asthmatic bronchi have a reduced susceptibility to forces from parenchymal tethering, which could favour greater airway narrowing when the airway is stimulated 6, 7. Many studies have focused on the responses of ASM after its isolation from the, airway, usually the trachea 8. In contrast, physiological responses described in intact bronchial airways isolated from asthmatics or animals models are scarce and the contributions that the bronchial wall may make to AHR in vivo remains controversial. A porcine model of AHR is presented in this study, which because of its size and ready availability allows the functional properties of different size bronchi to be investigated 9, 10. Early allergen-induced responses have previously been reported in the pig 7, 11. The preliminary aim of this current study was, therefore, to determine whether sensitization and repeated allergen exposure in pigs subsequently led to AHR. A further aim was to establish for the first time whether or not physiological responses in intact bronchi isolated from hyperresponsive pigs were increased. It was hypothesized that if AHR in vivo is due to physiological or morphological changes to the bronchial wall, then there should be an increase in responsiveness of bronchi isolated from the lung. In vitro responses were assessed in a bronchial segment, which preserves the structural components of the wall in their normal geometric relationship. This allows the smooth muscle to be exposed to contractile stimuli directly, via the adventitial surface, or via the airway lumen to simulate in vivo aerosol challenge.
Sensitization procedure Sixteen White/Landrace female pigs (10 kg) were studied. Eight test animals were sensitized to ovalbumin (OA) on day 0 and 7 as previously described 7. Four control animals were sham sensitized (saline and adjuvant) on corresponding days, while four naïve controls were housed for the same duration without receiving any injections.
Cutaneous responses
Aerosol challenge
Assessment of airways hyperresponsiveness in vivo
Assessment of airways hyperresponsiveness in vitro
Bronchi were electrically field stimulated (EFS, 60V, 20 Hz and 3 ms pulses) using platinum ring electrodes and a Grass S44 stimulator (Grass Instruments, Quincy, MA, USA). EFS responses were used to assess the optimum passive pressure and stretch of segments (5 cmH2O and 110% relaxed length, respectively, fig. 1
When a repeatable EFS response was obtained, a submaximal concentration of ACh, 1x104 M, was added to the bath, followed by washout, to provide a stable contraction history. Cumulative CRCs to ACh (1x1071x102 M) were then obtained by adding ACh to the bath bathing the adventitial surface of the segment. After recovery, a noncumulative ACh CRC (1x1071x101 M) was obtained by adding ACh to the fluid bathing the segment lumen 10, 13. Bronchial responsiveness in vitro was quantified as the maximum pressure developed in response to ACh (Emax) and the negative log of the ACh concentration that produced half the maximum pressure (pD2).
Morphology
Histology
Statistical analyses Correlations were determined from data obtained in controls, test and nonresponder animals, using the method of least squares. A p-value <0.05 was regarded as significant. Data are shown throughout as mean±sem, unless otherwise stated
Cutaneous responses Seven of eight test animals showed strong skin reactivity to intradermal OA on days 14 and 20. Positive responses occurred at a lower concentration on day 20 (geometric mean 0.019 mg·mL1, range 0.0010.01 mg·mL1) than day 14 (0.037 mg·mL1, range 0.010.1 mg·mL1, p<0.02). The remaining test animal had a weak response on both days (1 mg·mL1). Control animals showed no response to intradermal OA.
In vivo responses
Baseline RL and CL did not differ between test and controls on any study day Seven of the eight test pigs showed a strong increase in RL (255±26%, p<0.0001) and a corresponding decrease in CL (90±3%, p<0.0001) in response to OA aerosol on day 20 (fig. 2
Baseline RL did not differ between preallergen/saline exposure and the start of the CRC to ACh 1 hr later (tests: 18.1±1.8 cmH2O·L1·s and 17.8±1.5; controls: 18.7±1.4 and 18.3±1.7, respectively). Test pigs showed a significant left shift in the CRC to ACh on day 20 (p<0.0001) compared to baseline values on day 14 (fig. 3
Sensitivity to ACh doubled in test animals from day 14 to 20, but showed no change in controls. As illustrated in figure 3 Mean maximal RL increased from day 14 to 20 (289±36% and 387±68% respectively, p<0.05) in test animals but did not change in controls (295±49% on day 14 to 332±60% on day 20).
Nonresponder
Responsiveness of control and test bronchi in vitro Each pig yielded in vitro CRCs to adventitially applied ACh; however, only five animals per group produced maximum CRCs to lumenal ACh due to fatigue or development of a leak. The data from right and left bronchi were averaged, as no differences in responsiveness (pD2 and Emax) to ACh were found (table 2
Statistical analysis of the lumenal ACh CRC show a small, but significant, difference between test and control groups (p<0.03, fig. 5
Morphometry ASM area was increased in test pigs (0.064±0.004 mm, p<0.05) compared to controls (0.054±0.001) (table 3
Responsiveness in vivo versus in vitro Responsiveness of isolated bronchial segments to lumenal ACh was compared with in vivo responsiveness to aerosol ACh in control, test and nonresponder pigs. Reactivity to ACh in vivo (Rmax) showed a weak positive correlation with reactivity in vitro (Emax) (r=0.599, p=0.05). However, there was no correlation between sensitivity (log PC50) values in vitro and in vivo (r=0.441, p=0.175). Adventitial responses to ACh were also compared with in vivo responses. No correlation was found in reactivity (Rmax versus Emax, r=0.079, p=0.77) or sensitivity (log PC50, r=0.381, p=0.146).
Histology
This study is the first to report functional properties of whole bronchi in a model of AHR. The model incorporates the primary characteristics of asthma, namely airway narrowing, AHR and inflammation. A unique feature of this model is that the size and ready availability of the animal allows the airway physiology of small to medium size bronchi to be studied in vitro after demonstration of AHR in vivo. This allows comparisons to be drawn between physiological properties of the airway wall in vitro and lung responsiveness. In addition, the use of bronchial segments to assess airway function in vitro allows responsiveness to be determined separately for ASM (via adventitial application of ACh) and for the airway wall (via the lumen). The results from the present study imply that repeated allergen challenge in sensitized pigs produces complex changes affecting several components of the bronchial wall. Evidence suggests that ASM is less responsive in allergen exposed bronchi than controls, indicating that AHR in vivo may be associated with other factors which regulate ASM contraction, such as airway structure or external loads from the parenchyma. Bronchi from sensitized pigs had increased ASM, which is consistent with airway remodelling as seen in asthmatics 16. However, when assessed in vitro bronchi from sensitized pigs were less responsive to adventitial ACh than controls. Responsiveness could be influenced by inflammatory stimulation and also by the presence of smooth muscle cells with different contractile or secretory phenotypes 17. In some animal models, tracheal smooth muscle contraction is increased 13. There are fewer studies in bronchi, but one human study showed decreased smooth muscle force in bronchi obtained post mortem 5. The reduced bronchial response to adventitial ACh in the present study suggests that ASM force and sensitivity is decreased despite the presence of more ASM. At present, the authors have no information on contractions in more peripheral airways, which might show different levels of responsiveness. In contrast to the adventitial route, there was a modest rightward shift in the lumenal CRC of sensitized bronchi, the route considered to be more physiological. The small increase in lumenal sensitivity suggests the presence of some mechanism(s) within the airway wall which act to increase activation of ASM. Of particular importance is the lining epithelium, which if damaged leads to major increases in lumenal responsiveness due to increased drug penetration to the underlying smooth muscle 13. Although no gross alterations to epithelial morphology were observed in the test bronchi of this study, more subtle changes in epithelial permeability may have been present. The prevalence of early airway responses to inhaled allergen using this porcine model was 87%, which compares favourably with other allergic animal models 18. One sensitized pig failed to respond to OA aerosol and showed a poor cutaneous response compared to the other seven test animals. This biological variation is typical of species that are not highly inbred, hence some research groups use screening tests, such as cutaneous responses, to preselect the animals they study 11, 1820. The antigen-sensitized animals developed a typical wheal and flare response, suggesting a production of antigen-specific immunoglobulin-E (IgE) antibodies 12; whereas, neither naïve nor sham-sensitized control pigs responded to cutaneous antigen. A more sensitive index of sensitization would be advantageous. To date, it is not possible to measure porcine IgE concentrations directly, as there are no commercially-available antiporcine IgE monoclonal antibodies. However, significant advances have recently been made with the isolation of the pig IgE epsilon chain 21.
All control animals were exposed to an aerosol of saline, rather than OA in saline diluent, as repeated OA aerosol exposure may be sufficient to sensitize the animal in the absence of an initial antigen injection 22. Sham-sensitized pigs showed the same responses as naïve pigs (table 1 Multiple allergen exposure has been used in several animal models 2325 to induce some of the functional and struclural changes seen in asthma. In this study, three aerosol exposures to OA resulted in a mild inflammation in test animals particularly in the small airways. There was also an increase in ASM area, but no other changes in overall architecture of the tissue or degree of vascular disturbance distinguished test animals from controls. An aim of the present study was to determine whether differences in the responsiveness of lungs in vivo could be accounted for by properties of the isolated airway wall. Data from control, test and nonresponder pigs were combined providing a broad range of responses. The present study demonstrates a relationship between maximal responses to lumenal challenge in vivo and in vitro. Previous studies using rings or strips of smooth muscle 8 have failed to show such an association, possibly because the dissection procedure may compromise the epithelium and other structural features that contribute to responsiveness in vivo. More recently, Masaki et al. 26 showed a positive correlation between the effect of lumenally-applied ACh on tracheal narrowing in vitro and insufflation pressure in vivo in an OA-sensitized cohort of guinea pigs. In contrast, a study by Woisin et al. 27 found no correlation between in vivo and in vitro responsiveness in control and sensitized rabbits; however, the sensitized cohort failed to show hyperresponsiveness when compared to the controls. The present study extends these findings as it includes a cohort of normal pigs together with sensitized animals exhibiting clear AHR. The present results suggest that reactivity in vivo may be related to reactivity in the individual bronchus, as determined in vitro. There was no such relationship between sensitivities in vivo and in vitro. These findings are consistent with sensitivity arising as a result of more than one mechanism. Extrinsic airway mechanisms, as well as local airway alterations, could contribute to responsiveness as suggested by others 6. The present authors have previously shown that bronchi from test pigs are less compliant than controls 7, which is consistent with structural remodelling. In the present study, test animals showed airway wall remodelling in the form of increased airway smooth muscle area. This could lead to stiffer airways, which could be less prone to forces of interdependence in the lungs. Any reduction in the after-load on airway smooth muscle contraction, arising from forces of interdependence, might favour airway narrowing in vivo, but would not be apparent in the individual airway in vitro. Subsequent studies using this model may uncover, at the cellular level, mechanisms producing changes to airway function in the bronchial wall.
This article has been cited by other articles:
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||