Copyright ©ERS Journals Ltd 2001 Pulmonary sarcoidosis in children: a follow-up study1 Dept de Pneumologie Pediatrique-INSERM U515 and 2 Dept de Pathologie, Hôpital Armand Trousseau, Paris, France CORRESPONDENCE: A. Clement, Dept de Pneumologie Pediatrique, Hôpital Armand Trousseau, 26, Ave Dr Netter, 75012 Paris, France. Fax: 33 0144736725 Keywords: bronchoalveolar lavage, children, corticosteroids, pulmonary function tests, pulmonary sarcoidosis
Received: March 22, 2000
Progression of pulmonary sarcoidosis in children remains poorly documented. The aim of this work was to gather follow-up information on pulmonary outcomes in children with sarcoidosis and to obtain data of relevance to a discussion of the optimal length and regimen of glucocorticoid therapy. In the present study, the authors experience of pulmonary sarcoidosis in 21 children referred to the paediatric pulmonary department over a 10-yr period is reported with a documented follow-up of at least 4 yr. Evaluation of the disease during the follow-up included analysis of clinical manifestations, chest radiographs, pulmonary function tests with measurements of the vital capacity (VC), dynamic lung compliance (CL,dyn), lung transfer for CO (TL,CO), and arterial blood gases, as well as bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) with determination of total and differential cell counts. After initial evaluation the decision was a careful observation of four children without therapy. Corticosteroid treatment was initiated in 17 children. Analysis of results indicated that after 612 months of treatment most clinical manifestations of the disease and chest radiograph abnormalities disappeared, and beneficial effects on VC and TL,CO were apparent. After 18 months of steroids no benefit on pulmonary function tests could be noticed, with mainly persistence of alterations of CL,dyn. Results of BAL studies documented the presence of an alveolitis with increased lymphocyte populations throughout the follow-up. Relapses were observed in four children during tapering of prednisone; they were not reported after discontinuation of steroid therapy. Taken together data obtained in the presented population can lead to the following suggestions for the management of pulmonary sarcoidosis in children. BAL should be performed at the initial evaluation to document alveolitis; however, nothing seems to be gained from repeating this investigation during follow-up in the absence of specific reasons. Once the decision to initiate glucocorticoid therapy is made, 18 months may be a reasonable treatment duration. Discontinuation of therapy can be decided even if the pulmonary function tests remain abnormal, but the child should then be carefully monitored for a relapse. Sarcoidosis is a chronic inflammatory disease in which granulomatous lesions can develop in many organs, predominantly the lung 13. Its cause remains obscure but probably involves environmental and host factors. Therefore, the diagnosis of sarcoidosis is currently based on a combination of suggestive clinical features with histologically-documented noncaseating granulomas, in the absence of other known causes of granuloma formation. Sarcoidosis occurs chiefly in adults, with marked racial differences, and with estimated prevalences ranging <140 cases per 100,000 population 2. Although the incidence of sarcoidosis in children is difficult to assess, it is generally believed to be lower than in adults. Milman et al. 4 recently reported that the approximate calculated incidence of sarcoidosis in children in Denmark was 0.27 per 100,000 children per yr 4. Paediatric sarcoidosis is usually diagnosed in patients >10 yr, with a peak in 1315-yr group. The decision to treat pulmonary sarcoidosis in adults remains difficult, as there is no consensus on which patients should receive treatment 2, 5, 6. This is because the disease can stabilize or resolve without therapy. In particular, it is well recognized that acute pulmonary sarcoidosis remits spontaneously in nearly two-thirds of cases. Spontaneous remissions usually occur within the first few months after the diagnosis, but are occasionally seen after a longer period. The decision to treat adults with sarcoidosis must therefore be based on a set of factors including disease presentation, disease progression, and severity of pulmonary dysfunction 2, 79. Deciding when to treat is even more difficult in paediatric patients with pulmonary sarcoidosis. In addition, in patients selected for treatment, the optimal length of treatment remains unknown since there are no studies with sufficiently large patient populations to allow a comparative evaluation of several treatment strategies. The few reports in the literature suggest that pulmonary sarcoidosis may run a more aggressive course in children than in adults 1016. As pointed out by Pattishall and Kendig 15 in their review on paediatric sarcoidosis, data on the course of sarcoidosis in children are still meagre, and additional monitoring and reporting of the long-term effects of sarcoidosis in children are warranted 15. The aim of the present work was to gather follow-up information on pulmonary outcomes in children with sarcoidosis and to obtain data of relevance to a discussion of the optimal length and regimen of glucocorticoid therapy.
Study population The study population was recruited from the population of patients referred to the paediatric pulmonary department for sarcoidosis over a 10-yr period (19851995). Patient criteria for enrollment in this retrospective study including the following: 1) a biopsy-proven sarcoidosis with presence of noncaseating epithelial cell granuloma and exclusion of other granulomatous lung disorders; and 2) a documented follow-up of at least 4 yrs.
Initial evaluation Chest radiographs were analyzed independently by two readers and classified in a standard manner according to the traditional roentgenographic stages 2, 5. The pulmonary function tests included measurements of the vital capacity (VC), dynamic lung compliance (CL,dyn), lung transfer for CO (TL,CO), and arterial blood gases. Results of pulmonary function tests were expressed as a percentage of the predicted values (% pred) for height-matched children: CL,dyn and TL,CO values <75% and VC values <80% pred were considered as significantly decreased 17. BAL was performed during bronchoscopy under local anaesthesia, as previously described 16, 18. Briefly, patients were premedicated with atropine and midazolam, and local anaesthesia was achieved with topical lidocaine. The bronchoscope was wedged into a subsegmental bronchus of the lower right lobe. The volume of sterile normal saline instilled was equivalent to 3 mL·kg body weight1. The sterile solution at 37°C was injected in six aliquots and withdrawn by gentle aspiration. The first aliquot was used for microbiological studies. The remaining recovered fluid was pooled and filtered through sterile gauze, and samples were removed for total and differential cell counts. Lymphocyte subpopulation studies (CD4+, CD8+) were determined using a standard double immunofluorescence assay, as previously described 16, 18. Other investigations included blood laboratory tests with angiotensin-converting enzyme determination, eye examination by an ophthalmologist, and cardiac evaluation.
Corticosteroid therapy and follow-up The protocol of corticosteroid therapy used was the following. Oral prednisone was started at 1 mg·kg1· day1 for 68 weeks. A gradual reduction in the dosage was then initiated, guided by the disease progression to a level of 15 mg·day for at least 6 months. After this first period, the physician was at liberty to choose between a daily treatment or to institute an alternate day dosings. The steroid treatment was then decreased slowly over several months to the equivalent of 5 mg prednisone daily 16. In case of relapse, steroid treatment was increased up to 1 mg·kg1·day1 for the required amount of time necessary to control the disease, and then tapered again. During the follow-up, all patients were evaluated at several time points, and complete pulmonary investigations were repeated including chest radiographs, pulmonary function tests and BAL. Tolerance of glucocorticoid treatment was monitored with evaluation of effects on growth, hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis, and bone and glucose metabolism 19.
Statistical analyses
Presentation of the patients From the population of children referred to the department during the 10-yr period, 21 patients fulfilled the two criteria of enrollment in the study: a documented sarcoidosis and a follow-up of at least 4 yrs. Seven children were diagnosed before the age of 10 yrs. There was no difference in terms of sex. Twelve patients were Black. Characteristics of the patients are given in table 1
Organ involvement Complete investigation of the patients when referred to the department led to documented lung involvement in all of them (tables 2 and 3
Results of BAL at initial evaluation are listed in table 3
In addition to lung, organ involvement included mainly the liver, the eyes and the skin. In nine children an anterior uveitis was documented, whereas skin lesions were found in seven cases with mainly erythema nodosum and maculopapular eruptions. Presence of peripheral lymphadenopathy was noticed in five children. Cardiac abnormalities were found in three cases, with the presence of segmental defects on thallium-201 scans. Other organs involved included joints (two cases), kidney (two cases of renal dysfunction related to local infiltration of sarcoid granulomas), parotid glands (two cases), and, in one case each, stomach, tonsil, testis, and adenoids 2024. Results of serum angiotensin converting enzyme are listed in table 2
Diagnosis
Follow-up evaluation
Pulmonary function test results Pulmonary function tests were repeated several times during the follow-up. In the group of nontreated children, pulmonary function tests performed after 6 months of follow-up were normal (data not shown). They remained in the normal range of values throughout the study.
In the group of treated patients, results of pulmonary function tests obtained at the following time points: 6 months, 12 months, 18 months, and 34 yr, are reported in figures 13
After 6 months of daily prednisone, an alternate dosing treatment was introduced in eight children (patients 1421). To determine whether treatment regimen could have influenced disease progression, results of pulmonary function tests were compared in the following subgroups of treated children: subgroup A (patients 513) with daily treatment and subgroup B (patients 1421) with alternate dosing treatment. In subgroup A, no significant changes of the values of either VC, CL,dyn or TL,CO could be observed throughout the studied period. In subgroup B, results of CL,dyn were lower at the evaluation performed after 34 yr of follow-up (54.9±8.6%) compared to the values documented after 6 months of treatment (67.9±6.7%); however this difference did not reach statistical significance. As indicated in table 4
Bronchoalveolar results
In the present work, the course of pulmonary disease was analysed in a group of children with sarcoidosis. Data relevant to a discussion of glucocorticoid therapy strategies in paediatric sarcoidosis was obtained was obtained. This is important since at present there is an urgent need for defining the optimal length and regimen of glucocorticoid therapy in children. The study children were followed at a single centre and consequently were not representative of the overall paediatric population with a diagnosis of sarcoidosis. The characteristics of the patients call for a number of comments. Firstly, seven children were <10 yrs of age at diagnosis. Although paediatric sarcoidosis is most common at 1315 yrs of age, its age-specific incidence and prevalence remain uncertain, since it is, without doubt, an underdiagnosed condition 15. There are several reasons for this, the disease can be asymptomatic, particularly in its earliest stages; and in most countries children do not have routine annual chest radiographs. In the present work, a group of ophthalmologists referred all cases of paediatric uveitis of unknown origin to the authors department, a fact that explains the large proportion of patients with uveitis as the presenting symptom 20, 25. It is worth pointing out that among the seven children <10 yrs of age at diagnosis, three were investigated because of uveitis. Secondly, the data support previously reported differences in the racial distribution of sarcoidosis 2, 6. Marked racial differences in the incidence and prevalence of sarcoidosis have been reported by many authors. As an example, in the USA the prevalence of adult sarcoidosis is approximately three times higher in Blacks than in Caucasians. Various reports in the literature also indicate that race and ethnicity affect both the patterns of organ involvement and disease severity. The present findings are in keeping with these data: 12 children were Black; among the seven children <10 yrs of age at diagnosis, five were black; and the number of organs involved was higher in the Black than in the Caucasian children. At present, the management of sarcoidosis remains empirical as there is no consensus on which patients should be treated. This is because the course of the disease is difficult to predict in an individual patient. In addition, there is ample evidence that many adults experience spontaneous remission within six months of the diagnosis 2628. The degree of uncertainty surrounding the treatment of sarcoidosis is even greater in children than in adults since few paediatric studies have been published and long-term data from adults may not be relevant to children. In children, events related to lung growth may influence the course of the sarcoidosis 16. In a recent study, Marcille et al. 29 analysed data from 19 patients diagnosed with sarcoidosis in childhood and followed for a mean of 21 yrs. Pulmonary function tests remained abnormal in 68% of the patients. Although the adults included in this study may not be representative of the population of patients with a diagnosis of sarcoidosis during childhood, the findings suggest that the long-term outcome of sarcoidosis may be different in children and adults. In the present study, four patients were initially managed by watchful waiting. All four had mild symptoms, and three had normal pulmonary function test results; the exception (patient 3) had Löfgren's syndrome, which is known to be associated with a good prognosis. During follow-up, repeated pulmonary function testing showed normal results. The initial BAL fluid contained an increased population of lymphocytes. In the two children who underwent repeated BAL 1 and 2 yrs after the diagnosis, the results showed persistently high percentages of lymphocytes, with an increased CD4+/CD8+ ratio. Glucocorticoid treatment was initiated in 17 children. This proportion is high compared to studies in adults. The decision to give glucocorticoid therapy was based on the clinical presentation and symptoms, the sites and types of extrapulmonary disease, and the results of pulmonary function tests. At initial evaluation, all 17 children had alterations in VC, and/or CL,dyn, and/or TL,CO, and 11 had chest radiograph abnormalities. Oral prednisone was started at a dosage of 1 mg·kg1·day1, and the treatment regimen was subsequently adjusted based on disease progression. During the first 6 months, prednisone was given daily. All 17 children underwent repeated physical evaluations, during which the presence, nature, and severity of symptoms were noted. After 6 months, the chest radiograph had returned to normal in 10 of the 11 children with initial abnormalities. Improvements were seen in the VC and TL,CO. By contrast, no significant modifications in BAL results were recorded. After 12 and 18 months, pulmonary function test results were unchanged as compared to the 6 month evaluation, and all 17 children had normal chest radiographs. No further significant improvements were seen in pulmonary function tests performed during the 34 yr of follow-up. Interestingly, BAL studies showed a persistent increase in the proportion of lymphocytes throughout follow-up. These data confirm an earlier study in which it was found that the proportion of T-cells and the CD4+/CD8+ ratio remained abnormally high after 2 yrs of glucocorticoid therapy in eight children with sarcoidosis 16. It should be pointed out that the patients included in the present study received no drugs other than glucocorticoids.
The glucocorticoid treatment strategy during the first 6 months was similar in all 17 children. After 6 months, the physician in charge of the patient could either continue daily dosing or switch to alternate-day dosing. Nine patients were continued on daily dosing and eight were switched to alternate-day dosing. Three relapses occurred in the alternate-day group versus one in the daily group. Also, CL,dyn values were lower after 34 yrs in the alternate-day group. These results suggest that alternate-day dosing may be less beneficial than daily dosing. As in adult sarcoidosis, an issue of crucial importance is the optimal length of glucocorticoid treatment in paediatric sarcoidosis. Several studies have documented the short-term efficacy of glucocorticoids in adults. However, a recent statement on sarcoidosis recommends that glucocorticoid treatment should be continued for at least 12 months 2, 30. Pattishall and coworkers 14, 15, 31 concluded in their reviews on sarcoidosis in children that longer treatment may be required. In the patients of the present study, prolonged treatment was used empirically, the mean duration being 3 yrs. Resolution of most clinical manifestations and improvements in pulmonary function tests were noted during the first 612 months of glucocorticoid therapy. After 18 months, however, there were no further improvements in pulmonary function tests, and BAL cytology findings remained abnormal. These results are in keeping with the follow-up data obtained by Marcille et al. 29 in adults with a diagnosis of sarcoidosis during childhood. In the present study population, no relapses were observed after treatment discontinuation. In twp patients (table 4 The present study provides information on progression of the pulmonary disease. The most striking finding is the persistence of pulmonary function test alterations and of alveolitis manifesting as an increase in bronchoalveolar fluid lymphocytes. Glucocorticoid therapy provided some improvement in the pulmonary function test abnormalities but failed to affect the bronchoalveolar fluid cytology results. Taken in aggregate, these results suggest that the following proposals of management may be appropriate. Bronchoalveolar fluid should be performed at the initial evaluation to document alveolitis; however, nothing seems to be gained from repeating this investigation during follow-up in the absence of specific reasons. Once the decision to initiate glucocorticoid therapy is made, treatment efficacy should be evaluated based on the clinical manifestations, chest radiographs, and pulmonary function tests. The treatment can be stopped even if the pulmonary function tests remain abnormal, but the child should then be carefully monitored for a relapse. The optimal length of therapy remains an important issue. Several biological markers of disease activity are under study but cannot yet be used to guide treatment decisions 2, 3, 30. Based on the recent report of the sarcoidosis statement committee and on the follow-up data from the present study, 18 months may be a reasonable treatment duration 2, 30. Further follow-up studies are ongoing in the authors' department to gather additional information on pulmonary outcomes in paediatric sarcoidosis.
This article has been cited by other articles:
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||