Copyright ©ERS Journals Ltd 2001 Pulmonary gas exchange responses to histamine and methacholine challenges in mild asthmaServei de Pneumologia i Al.lèrgia Respiratòria, Dept de Medicina, Institut d'Investigacions Biomèdiques August Pi i Sunyer (IDIBAPS), Hospital Clínic, Universitat de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain CORRESPONDENCE: R. Rodriguez-Roisin, Servei de Pneumologia i Al.lèrgia Respiratòria, Hospital Clínic, Villarroel 170, Barcelona, Spain, 08036. Fax: 34 932275404 Keywords: airflow obstruction, bronchial challenge, mediators of inflammation, multiple inert gas elimination technique, ventilation-perfusion mismatch
Received: July 12, 2000
This study was supported by grants 99/0135 from the Fondo de Investigación Sanitaria (FIS), 1997 SGR00086 from the Comissionat per a Universitats i Recerca de la Generalitat de Catalunya, and by AstraZeneca. A.L. Echazarreta (1997) and F.P. Gómez (1996) were Research Fellows from the European Respiratory Society (ERS), J. Ribas was Research Fellow from the Comissió Interdepartamental de Recerca i Innovació Tecnológica (CIRIT) (1997), and E. Sala was awarded by a Hospital Clínic Research Fellowship (1997).
Histamine (HIST) produces greater changes in bronchial and pulmonary vasculature, and so may produce more gas exchange abnormalities, than methacholine (MTH) after inhalational challenge. The goals of this study were to compare the effects of HIST and MTH challenge on pulmonary gas exchange in patients with mild asthma at an equivalent degree of bronchoconstriction. Eleven patients were studied (mean±sem age, 22±1 yr; forced expiratory volume in one second (FEV1), 91±5% pred) using a randomized, double-blind cross-over design. Respiratory system resistance (Rrs), arterial blood gases, and ventilation-perfusion distributions were measured before and after HIST/MTH challenges when cumulative doses caused a 30% fall in FEV1. Compared with baseline, HIST and MTH provoked similar moderate to severe increases in Rrs (p<0.005 each), and mild to moderate decreases in arterial oxygen tension (Pa,O2) due to ventilation-perfusion abnormalities (dispersion of pulmonary blood flow -log SDQ-, 0.40±0.030.71±0.08 and 0.47±0.040.89±0.06; normal values <0.600.65), respectively, similar to those shown in mild to moderate acute asthma, without differences between them. For the same degree of airflow obstruction, both histamine and methacholine bronchoprovocations induce, in patients with mild asthma, very similar disturbances in ventilation-perfusion distribution and respiratory system resistance, suggesting similar mechanisms of airway narrowing. The strong evidence for inflammation in the airways of patients with asthma underpins the pathophysiology of the disease. Histamine (HIST) is a well known inflammatory mediator invoked in the pathogenesis of bronchial asthma. The release of this biogenic amine has been shown to be implicated in the development of several asthmatic symptoms including bronchial smooth muscle contraction, increased mucous secretion and bronchial vasodilatation through a nitric oxide (NO) synthesis-dependent mechanism 1, 2, and pulmonary vasoconstriction 3. The multiple inert gas elimination technique (MIGET) has shown that, in adult patients with mild asthma, methacholine (MTH) challenge produces mild to moderate arterial hypoxaemia caused by ventilation-perfusion (V'/Q') heterogeneity, namely, broadened unimodal blood flow and ventilation distributions related to maldistribution of ventilation, without changes in shunt and dead space 4, 5. By contrast, HIST challenge produces, in childhood asthma, moderate hypoxaemia due to the development of low V'/Q' areas, together with a bimodal pattern in the ventilation distribution 6. Although no information is available on V'/Q' response to HIST challenge in adult asthmatics, it is generally postulated, but never clearly proven, that bronchoprovocation with HIST enhances more hypoxaemia than with MTH. There is evidence for dissociation between expiratory airflow and gas exchange disturbances in asthma 7. This is consistent with the view that spirometry predominantly reflects airway narrowing in both larger and middle-sized airways, more closely related to bronchoconstriction, while changes in gas exchange reflect changes in more peripheral airways where inflammation is prominent. Patients with chronic asthma have an inflammatory cellular response involving both central and distal airways 8. The MIGET was used to study detailed pulmonary gas exchange after HIST and MTH challenges producing an equivalent degree of bronchoconstriction. It was postulated that HIST could be more deleterious to pulmonary gas exchange than MTH given its more potent vascular effects, hence typically inducing more V'/Q' disturbances, namely, areas with low V'/Q' units and bimodal blood flow patterns commensurate with the findings seen in acute severe asthma 6. This is the first time in which the responses of alveolar ventilation to pulmonary perfusion matching to both inhalational HIST and MTH challenges are investigated comparatively while inducing the same level of airway narrowing.
Study population Eleven nonsmoking patients (eight females) with mild asthma (22±1 yr; forced expiratory volume in one second (FEV1), 3.4±0.1 L (91±5% pred); FEV1/forced vital capacity (FVC), 79±3%; and provocative dose causing a 20% fall in FEV1 (PD20), 0.6±0.1 µmol) were recruited either from the outpatient Dept of the Hospital Clínic of Barcelona or through local advertisements for the study, which was approved by the Ethical Research Committee. Patients received financial renumeration for their participation. All subjects gave informed written consent after the purpose, risks and potential benefits of the study were explained to them. The inclusion criteria were: >18 yrs of age and <45 yrs; no respiratory infection or exacerbation of asthma within the preceding 6 weeks; FEV1 70% pred and 1.5 L after withholding adrenergic agents for 12 h and inhaled steroids for 24 h, and positive methacholine (PD20 <1.9 µmol) bronchial challenge on their first visit; no previous treatment with oral steroids; and absence of any systemic or cardiopulmonary disease other than asthma. All subjects were atopic, as judged by the presence of a positive response to skin prick tests (SPT) to one or more common aeroallergens. Maintenance therapy included aerosol short-acting (n=6) and long-acting (n=4) selective beta-adrenergics and/or inhaled glucocorticosteroids (n=6).
Measurements Blood samples were collected anaerobically through a catheter inserted into the radial artery. Arterial oxygen tension Pa,O2, carbon dioxide tension (Pa,CO2) and pH were analysed in duplicate using standard electrodes and haemoglobin concentration was measured by a Co-oximeter (Ciba Corning 860 System. Ciba Corning Diagnostics Corporation, Meadfield, MA, USA). Oxygen uptake (V'O2) and CO2 production (V'CO2) were calculated from mixed expired O2 and CO2 concentrations (CPX/D, MCG Medical Graphics Corporation, St. Paul, MN, USA). Both minute ventilation (V'E) and respiratory frequency (fR) were measured using a calibrated Wright spirometer (Respirometer MK8, BOC-Medical, Essex, UK). The alveolar-arterial oxygen tension gradient (PA-a,O2) was calculated according to the alveolar gas equation using the measured respiratory exchange ratio (RER). MIGET was used to estimate the distributions of ventilation-perfusion (V'/Q') ratios without sampling mixed venous inert gases 12. In brief, an intravenous infusion, was started and maintained of six inert gases dissolved in saline for 45 min before measurements while the infusion rate was 5 mL·min1. Duplicate samples of arterial and mixed expired gases were processed separately for six inert gas concentration measurements by gas chromatography. From the measured concentrations, retention and excretion values for each of the six inert gases were calculated, and retention-solubility and excretion-solubility curves were constructed. The distribution of ventilation and blood flow was estimated from these curves. With this approach, cardiac output (Q') needs to be directly measured by dye dilution technique (DC-410; Waters Instruments Inc., Rochester, MN, USA) using 5 mg bolus of indocyanine green injected through a catheter placed percutaneously in an arm vein, while mixed venous inert gas concentrations are computed from mass balance equations. The duplicate samples of each set of measurements were treated separately, the final data resulting in the average of variables calculated from both sets at each point in time. A three-lead electrocardiogram, heart rate (HR) and systemic arterial pressure (Ps) and arterial oxygen saturation(Sa,O2) through a pulse oximeter (HP M1166A, Hewlett-Packard, Boblingen, Germany) were continuously recorded throughout the whole study (HP 7830A Monitor and HP 7754B Recorder, Hewlett-Packard, Waltham, MA, USA).
Study design
Statistical analysis
Baseline conditions Eleven patients were studied with mild asthma without clinical or functional differences between HIST and MTH study days. V'/Q' relationships were mostly within the normal range 14 (table 1
Histamine and methacholine responses After HIST and MTH challenges (cumulative doses, 0.38±0.13 mg and 0.22±0.05 mg), FEV1 decreased (by 37±1% and 38±2%) and both Rrs (by 83% and 78%) and V'E increased, respectively. fR, HR, Ps and Q' remained unchanged; V'O2 increased after MTH only (figs. 1 and 2
Following HIST and MTH challenges, Pa,O2 fell (by 26% and 28%) and PA-a,O2 increased (ranges, 4.845.2 and 15.438.5 mmHg); both Pa,CO2 and pH (7.41±0.01 and 7.40±0.01), respectively, did not vary. Similarly, basal V'/Q' relationships mildly to moderately worsened after HIST and MTH challenges, as shown by increases of both log SDQ and log SDV (HIST ranges, 0.331.05 and 0.591.06; and, MTH, 0.621.15 and 0.700.98, respectively; normal values, <0.600.65 14), and/or of an overall index of V'/Q' heterogeneity (DISP R-E*; root mean square difference among measured retentions (R) and excretions (E) of the inert gases (except acetone) corrected for the dead space; normal values <3.0). Distributions of pulmonary blood flow and alveolar ventilation modestly broadened in all patients. The mean V'/Q' ratio of the perfusion distribution (Q) showed a trend to decrease after HIST (from 0.70±0.040.62±0.03) or decreased after MTH (from 0.75±0.050.62±0.04) (p<0.05). Similarly, the mean V'/Q' ratio of the ventilation distribution (V) increased after both challenges (HIST, 0.86±0.071.19± 0.10; and, MTH, 1.01±0.081.44±0.08; p<0.0001 each). By contrast, there were no changes in intrapulmonary shunt, areas with low V'/Q' units or dead space (percentage of ventilation to units with V'/Q' ratio >100). Mean FEV1 after the completion of all measurements was still decreased (HIST, by 18±3%; and, MTH, by 19±3%, p<0.001 each, respectively). All in all, there were no differences in the changes seen with HIST compared to MTH. The difference in log SDV after HIST challenge as compared to baseline was correlated with the baseline log SDV (r=0.75, p<0.02). Likewise, the differences in Pa,O2 and PA-a,O2 following HIST compared with baseline were correlated with those shown in log SDQ (r=0.79, p<0.01; and 0.68, p<0.04, respectively), and those in Pa,O2 as compared to those observed in DISP R-E* (r=0.68, p<0.04). The difference in FEV1 following MTH as compared to baseline was correlated with the baseline FEV1 value (r=0.84, p<0.001). No correlations were shown in any of the variables between pre- to post-HIST and MTH challenges.
A subanalysis was performed in the subset of the six patients using inhaled glucocorticoids to ensure that there was no effect or a lack of an effect with regard to any of the parameters investigated. Differences in pre- to post-HIST and MTH challenges between patients with and without inhaled steroids were not significant (fig. 1
The major finding in the present study was that HIST provoked, in patients with mild asthma, similar V'/Q' defects than MTH while undergoing an equivalent degree of bronchoconstriction. After both challenges, patients showed mild to moderate arterial hypoxaemia and/or increased PA-a,O2, due to V'/Q' mismatching. This was essentially characterized by broadly unimodal blood flow and ventilation distributions, while shunt and dead space remained unaltered; areas with low and high V'/Q' units were never observed. Both post-challenge V'/Q' findings were akin to those shown in adult patients during mild to moderate acute asthma 15, or after MTH 4, exercise 16 or allergen challenges 17, but at variance with those shown in children after HIST 6. HIST challenge in childhood asthma uniquely developed a bimodal V'/Q' distribution centred around a V'/Q' ratio of 10, without changes in dead space, along with mild to moderate increases in the log SDQ 6. These V'/Q' defects, never observed in adult asthmatics after different bronchial challenges 46, 16, 17, may be related to both gas trapping and lung hyperinflation whose pathogenic mechanism remains elusive. In contrast with this hypothesis, however, HIST challenge did not induce areas with low V'/Q' areas nor bimodal blood flow distributions, as shown in more life-threatening forms of acute asthma 18 or during acute experimental canine bronchoconstriction induced by nebulized MTH 19, 20, HIST, or ascaris suum extract 20, or more V'/Q' disturbances than those observed after MTH. There were no correlations between spirometric or lung mechanic changes and gas exchange findings during both inhalational challenges. There was a good agreement, however, between respiratory and inert gas exchange indices after HIST. The latter correlations were seen because the principal extrapulmonary factors modulating arterial oxygenation, such as minute ventilation, cardiac output, and oxygen uptake, additional to V'/Q' inequalities, remained unaltered (or changed slightly) after HIST. However, since this study comprised a small number of subjects, a type 2 error may be too large to be confident that there were no major differences in variables after challenges. The similarities between the degree of pulmonary gas exchange disturbances shown after HIST to those observed after MTH may indicate that the mechanisms of bronchoconstriction in both of these challenges are similarly heterogeneous in their anatomical basis, being mediated in both central and peripheral airways. Furthermore, areas with low V'/Q' ratio did not change after both challenges, suggesting a relatively well preserved active hypoxic pulmonary vasoconstriction, a very efficient collateral ventilation, and/or that airway occlusion was never complete 15, 18. Although it is generally held that gas exchange impairment in asthma is mainly induced by small airways 7, experimental studies have shown that the V'/Q' imbalance becomes much more disrupted with larger airways narrowing 15. In a previous study 4, the increases of airway resistance after MTH correlated with those of Log SDV, indicating that maldistribution of ventilation due to widespread airway narrowing was the most likely mechanism of MTH-induced V'/Q' inequalities. In another work in patients with adult asthma 5, in contrast to airway conductance changes, there was no difference in the V'/Q' responses whether the deposition of MTH was in central or peripheral airways. It could be argued that part of the HIST challenge-induced V'/Q' disturbances may be caused by airway plasma leakage due to its potent bronchial vascular effects. MTH may also have airway vasoactive properties, potentially related to a NO-mediated vascular response 21 and aerosolized MTH may result in substantial increases in bronchial blood flow in sheep 22. Although HIST may have more intense bronchial vascular effects than MTH, HIST-induced reinforcement of hypoxic pulmonary vasoconstriction 3 could facilitate a better matching between ventilation and perfusion, thereby minimizing its more deleterious effect on V'/Q' balance. Histamine in response to hypoxia is released from mast cells clustered primarily around the pulmonary vasculature resulting in vasoconstriction 3. There were no differences between patients with and without regular inhaled steroid therapy. A previous anti-inflammatory treatment could favourably modulate the challenge response. Asthmatic patients using inhaled steroid therapy may have less small airway inflammation and thereby be more prone to exhibit fewer post-challenge V'/Q' defects than steroid-naive patients at an equivalent degree of airflow obstruction 7, 18. In summary, for the same degree of bronchoconstriction, histamine challenge does not induce more marked gas exchange disturbances than methacholine.
The authors are grateful to F. Burgos, J. Cardús, C. Gistau, T. Lecha, M. Simó and Carmen Argaña, from the Lung Function Laboratory for their outstanding continuous technical support.
This article has been cited by other articles:
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||